A judge sits in court waiting to try regulatory matters

ASIC Governance Imperatives for 2026

After the significant events of 2025, we believe that ASIC’s enforcement stance entering 2026 is clear and increasingly uncompromising. The key message for directors of Australian Financial Services Licensees (AFSLs) is that governance failure is no longer a background risk, but a primary enforcement focus for ASIC. In our opinion, ASIC is escalating litigation, pursuing criminal referrals, and holding individual directors accountable where governance weaknesses result in consumer harm or market misconduct.

It is critical to note that ASIC isn’t just warning directors, it’s prosecuting them. Licensees need to acknowledge that governance failure is now the regulator’s primary focus and adapt accordingly. Simply put, Directors who miss red flags, rely passively on management, or fail to challenge conflicted business models face an increased risk of litigation, civil penalties, and potential criminal referrals. ASIC’s approach aligns closely with APRA’s expectations under CPS 220 and CPS 510, which place ultimate accountability for risk governance, culture, and control effectiveness squarely with the board. In the wake of Shield and First Guardian, passive oversight, reliance on management assurances, and retrospective remediation are no longer defensible positions. Directors are expected to demonstrate active, informed, and disciplined governance, or risk regulatory action.

Culture is not a secondary risk exposed by enforcement, but a primary governance control through which ASIC evaluates board effectiveness.


1. ASIC’s 2026 Enforcement Focus

In a variety of public statements, ASIC has unequivocally stated when it will act decisively and publicly to enforce the law and restore stakeholder confidence. Boards should therefore assume that these priorities will directly inform surveillance, investigation, and litigation decisions. In our view, Directors and Responsible Managers should treat these as warnings as clear and present dangers.


Key Enforcement Areas:


Regulatory Posture:

The regulator’s focus on the effectiveness of licensees’ governance frameworks means that Boards are expected to anticipate these risks. Plausible deniability is no longer a credible defence to material governance failures or compliance breakdowns. Even for emerging risks, assertions that issues were unforeseen are unlikely to mitigate liability.

ASIC has made clear it will litigate where necessary and refer criminal conduct where thresholds are met. It will seek personal accountability. Boards are expected to identify issues early, escalate appropriately, and remediate effectively; they must pre-empt harm, not simply react once it occurs.


2. Governance and Culture

“Culture isn’t about values on a wall, it’s about the behaviours people choose under real-world pressures… Regulators and auditors are catching up to this truth, reframing culture as something observable, measurable, and auditable: behaviour.”

Priya Giuliani,  “Culture isn’t a Patch: It’s the Platform”

As inconvenient as it may be, it’s essential to recognise that ASIC’s focus is not limited to fraud or overt misconduct. Increasingly, enforcement action targets the governance failures that allow misconduct to arise, persist, or go unchallenged (ASIC v Cassimatis (No 8) [2016] FCA 1023).

This framing is consistent with APRA’s supervisory approach, which treats governance, risk culture, and board oversight as foundational controls and critical failure points (APRA Supervisory Approach).

The Shield and First Guardian collapses have not been interpreted by ASIC as rogue failures, but as systemic and broadly consistent issues. Across multiple regulated entities, ASIC found board-level inaction, tolerance of risk, ineffective oversight, and deference to, and reliance on, management without independent verification (ASIC Media Releases – Fund Collapses). Historic failures determine future activities, and the regulator’s increasing focus on the effectiveness of licensees’ governance frameworks means that Boards are, and will be, expected to anticipate these risks. Neither roles, functional responsibilities, nor ignorance are credible defences to material governance failures or compliance breakdowns. Even for emerging risks, assertions that issues were unforeseen are unlikely to mitigate liability.


Key Takeaways:

  • Governance failure is a primary driver of enforcement outcomes. Regulators routinely characterise misconduct as the product of deficient board oversight rather than isolated operational error (ASIC Corporate Governance Taskforce).
  • Culture is treated as a control. Incentive structures, accountability mechanisms, and “tone from the top” (escalation behaviour, tolerance of overrides, response to adverse data and treatment of dissent) are assessed as governance settings, not abstract concepts (APRA Information Paper – Risk Culture). Culture can be assessed by consideration of:
    • Board papers,
    • Decision records,
    • Unresolved red flags,
    • Incentive persistence despite known harm,
    • Remediation timing.
  • Gatekeepers are in scope. Directors, trustees, platform operators, and licensees are expected to challenge risk-taking behaviour, rather than merely observe it. (ASIC on Gatekeepers)

3. Considering Risks

ASIC’s enforcement priorities translate into identifiable board-level risks. APRA’s prudential standards similarly require boards to identify, oversee, and manage material risks within a structured risk management framework (APRA Prudential Standard CPS 220 – Risk Management). Both regulators provide the parameters that define their expectations of Directors and Management.

Regulator FocusBoard-Level RiskRequired Oversight
Misleading pricingFalse/misleading disclosure; civil penaltiesAssurance over customer comms and remediation
Product governance & DDOProducts sold outside target marketActive review of TMDs, data, and triggers
Adviser supervisionHigh-risk or conflicted adviceEscalation frameworks; red flag monitoring
Platform/product due diligenceInappropriate or risky product offeringsOversight of product approval/removal processes
Culture and incentivesSales over compliance; poor accountabilityRegular review of incentive structures
Reporting and recordkeepingLodgement failures; inadequate recordsControls, attestations, board-level sign-off

4. The Death of Plausible Deniability

ASIC is not creating new expectations but simply applying long-standing statutory duties with renewed intensity. To be clear, directors’ obligations under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) are now central to enforcement strategy and are reinforced by both APRA and ASIC’s governance standards. Their expectations of Directors are based on clear obligations and explicit statutory requirements, including:

  • Care and diligence (s180) requires informed, active oversight. Directors who fail to interrogate risks or respond to red flags face personal exposure (ASIC v Rich [2003] NSWSC 85). Practically, ASIC is targeting directors who ignore red flags, who fail to interrogate risks, challenge assumptions, or respond to warning signs.
  • Good faith (s181): Directors must act in the company’s and clients’ lawful interests. Board decisions must align with the company’s legal and ethical obligations, not solely with short-term commercial outcomes.
  • Misuse of position/information (ss182–183): Directors must avoid enabling conflicts of interest, preferential deals, or insider advantage. Watch for conflicts and avoid abuse.
  • Conflict management: Poorly managed remuneration, referral, or product conflicts remain a persistent enforcement trigger. Failure to identify or address conflicts is a direct liability risk.
  • Insolvent trading (s588G): ASIC increasingly links this to governance failures when capital, systems or remediation capacity are inadequate.[iii]

These are not new obligations. Cases such as *ASIC v Cassimatis (Storm), ASIC v RI Advice, and the Shield Enforcement actions confirm that directors who “trust but do not verify” will be held accountable; the failure to interrogate risk, challenge assumptions, or escalate warnings is enough to expose a director personally. In practice, this requires:

  • independent data validation,
  • probing adverse metrics,
  • commissioning second-line or external reviews,
  • testing management optimism.

5. Anticipate ASIC

In reality, good luck (and good markets) can often conceal and mitigate the effects of defective governance frameworks.

Unfortunately, for some Licensees, ASIC’s enforcement strategy in 2026 won’t focus solely on outcomes; it will also explicitly consider the decision-making processes and governance posture that enabled them. In practice, this means Boards will be expected to demonstrate what they knew, what they did, and why they did it, both before and after the failure.

The following diagnostic prompts are designed to pressure-test directors’ governance approach. These are not questions ASIC will definitely ask, but they are questions Boards should already be asking themselves to inform Board effectiveness reviews and to prepare for regulatory engagement or surveillance.


Risk Identification and Escalation

  1. What emerging risks did the board identify — and how?
  2. What adverse trends or indicators were visible before the issue crystallised?
  3. When red flags appeared, how were they escalated, challenged, and tracked?

Oversight of High Risk Activities

  1. What did we know about high-risk products, channels, or customer cohorts?
  2. How did we test management assurances around these risks?
  3. Were the warning signs independently validated or externally reviewed?

Conflict Management and Incentives

  1. How were conflicts of interest identified and managed in practice?
  2. Were sales-driven incentives challenged where misalignment was evident?
  3. Did anyone raise dissent — and how was it handled?

Remediation and Accountability

  1. How did the board ensure remediation was timely, complete, and effective? (ASIC – Remediation Guidance)
  2. Did accountability structures drive root cause correction or just surface fixes?
  3. Was poor conduct tolerated, rationalised, or repeated?

Directors should assume that if an issue attracts ASIC’s attention, these questions will be asked, whether directly or through forensic review of board papers, decision records, and timelines. The credibility of your answers will be shaped less by intention than by the observable quality of your governance decisions.

ASIC applies these expectations equally to executive and non-executive directors, so asserting a limited mandate or claiming non-operational involvement will carry little weight.


6. Five Strategic Responses

  1. Shift from Assurance to Anticipation. Transition from validating past compliance to proactively challenging business models, incentive schemes, and risk blind spots. This requires an environmental design that focuses on how incentives are set, what information reaches the board, whether dissent is structurally protected and whether speed is rewarded over quality.
  2. Reframe Culture as Governance Infrastructure. Treat culture not as an abstract “soft” element but as an auditable, strategic control system influencing outcomes and accountability.
  3. Implement Board-Level Pre-mortem and Red Teaming: Institutionalise dissent, alternative scenario planning, and risk-based simulation exercises to stress-test board assumptions.
  4. Reclaim Ethical Governance. Embed decision-making frameworks that go beyond legal sufficiency to include stakeholder impact, moral duty, and long-term value.
  5. Develop a Regulatory Convergence Map. Develop a unified director’s lens across regulatory expectations to prevent silos and reinforce coherent governance logic.

Redefining Board Risk

In 2026, governance will be judged by outcomes, not intent. ASIC will pursue directors who allow systems to fail, culture to erode, or risks to remain unchallenged. For AFSL holders, the boardroom has become a frontline compliance function. Directors must be able to demonstrate that they earned their protections well before they need to rely on them.

If you need support setting up your governance systems for success, get in touch with our team.

Further reading

If you enjoyed this article, you might also like:


Frequently Asked Questions

What does ASIC mean by “governance failure”?

ASIC typically refers to board-level deficiencies, such as inadequate oversight, failure to respond to red flags, weak challenge to management, and ineffective risk or compliance frameworks that enable misconduct or consumer harm.

Are non-executive directors exposed to the same enforcement risk?

Yes. ASIC and the courts have consistently indicated that non-executive status does not reduce directors’ duties of care, diligence, and oversight under the Corporations Act.

How does culture factor into ASIC enforcement?

ASIC increasingly treats culture as an observable control. Incentives, escalation practices, treatment of dissent, and responses to adverse information are used as evidence of governance effectiveness.

What is meant by the “death of plausible deniability”?

Boards can no longer rely on a lack of knowledge or delegation to management as a defence. Directors are expected to actively seek, test, and challenge information relevant to material risks.

What evidence does ASIC examine when assessing directors?

ASIC commonly reviews board papers, decision records, risk reports, escalation logs, remediation timelines, and whether known issues were challenged or tolerated.

Keep exploring

Subscribe

Every fortnight “Three Hit Tuesday” delivers thought leadership, considered analysis and insights that will help you improve your advice, more effectively manage your regulatory risks and make you better informed than your peers.

AS-Subscribe Form

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We respect your privacy. We know everyone says that, but we promise that we won’t sell your contact details to dodgy telemarketers, spam your email or otherwise exploit your trust.

Step 1 of 8 - Your Role

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Assess your ASIC exposure

Answer a few targeted questions to identify where your compliance may not stand up under ASIC review.

Takes less than 2 minutes. No preparation required.

What best describes your role?