FSCP Outcomes

Diving into the FSCP Outcomes Register: A Comprehensive Look at Advisory Misconduct and Regulatory Responses

The Financial Services and Credit Panel (FSCP) plays a crucial role in upholding professional standards and maintaining public confidence in the financial services industry. Through its Outcomes Register, the Panel provides insights into the types of misconduct financial advisers can engage in and the corresponding regulatory actions taken. 

In this article, we’ll dive deep into the Outcomes Register, examining the Panel’s decisions, reasoning, and any accompanying media releases while exploring the rationale behind the chosen actions and the absence of action against licensees.

Legend:

s921E Code of Ethics

s961B  Best Interests Duty

s961G Appropriateness

s961J Client Priority Rule

1. 29/05/2023 – Mr S

Alleged Misconduct: Mr S contravened sections 1041H and 921E(3) of the Corporations Act 2001 by impersonating a client during two telephone conversations with a bank.

Panel’s Decision: The panel determined that the adviser had breached the law and required the adviser to provide the reports for three successive compliance audits undertaken by the Licensee. 

Our view: The Sitting Panel likely considered increased supervision by the authorising licensee an appropriate response to isolated misconduct that neither benefited the adviser nor caused detriment to the client.

2. 20/06/2023 – Mr M

Alleged Misconduct: Mr M contravened sections 961B(1), 961G, 1041E(1), and 921E(3) of the Corporations Act 2001 by recommending that cold-called clients switch their superannuation using unreasonable retirement projections and without considering insurance. The recommendations were made, and the implementation was done on the same day. 

Panel’s Decision: A written direction was issued under section 921L(1)(a)(iii) of the Corporations Act 2001, requiring Mr M to engage, at his own cost, an independent person to audit 20 SOAs and report back to ASIC.

Our View: Given that the problematic advice had been pre-vetted by his Licensee, the Panel may have opted for a targeted remedial approach, requiring independent oversight and auditing of Mr M’s advice to ensure he improves his practices and complies with his obligations. It’s an important precedent for several reasons. First, the authorised representative (and not the authorising licensee) is personally liable for the remediation costs. Second, the decision to require an independent audit of the adviser’s advice and process may reflect the Panel’s recognition of the Licensee’s failure to detect and prevent the adviser’s failures.

3. 26/07/2023 – Mr X

Alleged Misconduct: Concerns were raised that Mr X contravened sections 961B(1) and 961G of the Corporations Act 2001 by providing three clients with layered advice where it was not appropriate. The Panel alleged that the adviser failed to identify his clients’ relevant circumstances and objectives, failed to collect relevant information and relied on generic, unsubstantiated reasons for replacing insurance. Further, the adviser failed to disclose the consequences and implications of replacing superannuation products. 

Panel’s Decision: A written direction was issued under section 921L(1)(a)(iii) of the Corporations Act 2001, requiring Mr X to engage, at his own cost, an independent person to audit 20 SOAs (10 related to insurance and ten related to superannuation) and report back to ASIC. The independent expert’s recommendations must be acknowledged and formally responded to by the adviser’s Licensee, and any deviation must be reported to ASIC.

Our View: After evaluating the evidence, the Panel may have been satisfied that Mr X had contravened the relevant sections of the Corporations Act but needed to be convinced that the failures were intentional. Although the adviser’s competency and training may have played a part, it may be reasonable to conclude from the decision that the Licensee’s acts, omissions or policies contributed to the advice failures. In our view, this decision is consistent with the Panel’s approach of differentiating between process and conduct issues and trying to remediate process issues before taking administrative action.

4. 07/08/2023 – Mr K

Alleged Misconduct: Mr K contravened sections 961B(1), 961G, 961J(1) and 921E(3) of the Corporations Act 2001 by failing to act in his client’s best interests by inappropriately scoping advice to exclude retirement planning, rolling over superannuation without considering existing products, providing inappropriate advice regarding insurance and breaching the Code of Ethics.

Panel’s Decision: A written reprimand was issued under section 921T(1) of the Corporations Act 2001.

Our View: The Panel may have considered that this misconduct was not the result of process failures but commercial choices made by the adviser. While the Panel may not have believed the contraventions justified more severe administrative actions, the reprimand adequately flags the significance of the adviser’s contraventions.

5. 31/08/2023 – Mr O

Alleged Misconduct: Mr O contravened sections 946B(3A), 961B(1) and 921E(3) of the Corporations Act 2001 by failing to keep adequate records of advice provided to three clients. The Panel alleged that personal advice was presented as general advice, and the records maintained by the adviser could not provide evidence of the process followed by the adviser. 

Panel’s Decision: A written direction was issued under section 921L(1)(a)(iii) of the Corporations Act 2001, requiring Mr O to engage, at his own cost, an independent person to audit 10 SOAs and report back to ASIC.

Our View: The Panel opted for a targeted remedial approach, requiring independent oversight and auditing of Mr. O’s advice to ensure he improves his practices and complies with his obligations. This decision is consistent with the Panel’s approach of differentiating between process and conduct issues and trying to remediate process issues before taking administrative action. Importantly, although disclosure may be far less critical than engagement and consent, the decision reinforces the importance of documented advice processes.

6. 31/08/2023 – Mr H

Alleged Misconduct: Mr H contravened sections 946B(3A), 961B(1) and 921E(3) of the Corporations Act 2001 by failing to keep adequate records of advice provided to three clients. The Panel alleged that personal advice was presented as general advice, and the records maintained by the adviser could not provide evidence of the process followed by the adviser. 

Panel’s Decision: A written direction was issued under section 921L(1)(a)(iii) of the Corporations Act 2001, requiring Mr H to engage, at his own cost, an independent person to audit 10 SOAs and report back to ASIC.

Our View: The Panel may have opted for a targeted remedial approach, requiring independent oversight and auditing of Mr. H’s advice, because these were process failures rather than conduct issues. This decision is consistent with the Panel’s approach of differentiating between process and conduct issues and trying to remediate process issues before taking administrative action. Nothing suggests that the same licensee authorised Mr O and Mr H. Still, the similarities between these decisions  (and the similar advice failures) indicate that the Licensee’s decisions, directions and processes may have contributed to these failures.

7. 10/08/2023 – Mr E

Alleged Misconduct: Mr E contravened sections 961B(1) and 921E(3) of the Corporations Act 2001 by providing an insurance recommendation without being authorised to provide insurance advice (and despite having this brought to his attention before he provided the recommendation).

Panel’s Decision: A written reprimand was issued under section 921T(1) of the Corporations Act 2001.

Our View: The Panel may have considered that this was not the result of process failures but of deliberate or reckless choices made by the adviser. While the Panel may not have believed the contraventions justified more severe administrative actions, the reprimand adequately flags their significance.

8. 08/09/2023 – Ms D

Alleged Misconduct: Ms D contravened sections 961B(1), 961G, 1041E(1), and 921E(3) of the Corporations Act 2001 by failing to make reasonable inquiries, providing inappropriate advice, engaging in misleading conduct, and breaching the Code of Ethics regarding cashflow, investment, superannuation, and insurance advice provided to two clients.

Panel’s Decision: A written direction was issued under section 921L(1)(a)(iii) of the Corporations Act 2001, requiring Ms D to engage an independent person to audit 10 SOA, review her advice processes and implement any recommended changes.

Our View: Context is critical, but the Panel seems to have recognised that targeted remedial action would address Ms D’s contraventions and prevent their recurrence. Given the small sample, the Panel may have concluded that since the failures were not the result of negligence, recklessness or deliberate intent, the most appropriate response would be to require the adviser to improve her advice process. This decision reflects the Panel’s commitment to upholding professional standards while allowing advisers to rectify their practices and improve their competency under independent oversight.

9. 12/09/2023 – Mr V

Alleged Misconduct: Concerns were raised that Mr V contravened sections 961B(1) and 961G of the Corporations Act 2001 by failing to identify the need for retirement planning advice, failing to make reasonable inquiries about cashflow, and failing to determine the appropriateness of an aggressive investment strategy.

Panel’s Decision: No action was taken against Mr. V.

Our View: While acknowledging that Mr V could have done more in certain areas, the Panel may not have believed the failures warranted action such as a warning or reprimand. Alternatively, they may have considered that the failures were not material, did not cause client detriment or that the compliance and conduct issues had already been adequately addressed. In any event, this decision highlights the Panel’s discernment in evaluating the significance of alleged misconduct and reserving formal action for more severe cases.

10. 21/09/2023 – Mr T

Alleged Misconduct: Mr T contravened sections 946A, 947D(2)(a)(iii), and 921E(3) of the Corporations Act 2001 by failing to include advice given to a client about using the downsizer rule in an SOA and failing to comply with SOA requirements for switching advice provided to two clients.

Panel’s Decision: A written warning was issued under section 921T(1)(b) of the Corporations Act 2001.

Our View: The Panel opted for a written warning. They may have recognised the competency issue but considered the failure immaterial or adequately mitigated. The decision to issue a written warning effectively reinforces the need to comply with SOA requirements while allowing Mr T the opportunity to rectify his conduct and avoid further breaches.

11. 11/10/2023 – Mr P

Alleged Misconduct: Mr P had clients sign blank off-market transfer forms, which he photocopied and completed to transfer multiple securities, breaching the Code of Ethics by failing to act with integrity.

Panel’s Decision: No action was taken against Mr. P.

Our View: While acknowledging the breach of the Code of Ethics, the Panel noted the extraneous factors and the significant remedial steps the licensee took. It’s unclear what these factors were or why and to what extent subsequent remediation minimises compliance failures. Still, the adviser’s intent and the lack of client detriment may be relevant considerations. This decision demonstrates the Panel’s willingness to consider mitigating circumstances and the actions taken by licensees to address misconduct.

12. 04/12/2023 – Mr Timothy Anderson (Media Release: 23-330MR)

Alleged Misconduct: Mr Anderson was an undischarged bankrupt under administration, expected to be discharged on May 17, 2025.

Panel’s Decision: A registration prohibition order was issued under section 921L(1)(c) of the Corporations Act 2001, cancelling Mr Anderson’s registration as a relevant provider from December 7, 2023, until after May 17, 2025.

Our View: The panel’s decision was based on the real risk of harming public confidence in the financial services industry and ASIC’s reputation if an undischarged bankrupt person can continue providing personal advice. The media release (23-330MR) highlighted the Panel’s concern about Mr. Anderson’s lack of professional judgment and insight regarding his bankruptcy.

13. 01/12/2023 – Mr Stephen Rogers (Media Release: 23-335MR)

Alleged Misconduct: The Panel found that Mr Rogers contravened sections 961B(1), 961G, 961J(1), 1041H(1), and 921E(3) of the Corporations Act 2001. He failed to provide appropriate advice, recommended unsuitable products, prioritised his interests, engaged in misleading conduct, and breached the Code of Ethics.

Panel’s Decision: A written order was issued under sections 921K(1)(a) and 921L(1)(c) of the Corporations Act 2001, prohibiting Mr. Rogers’ registration as a relevant provider until after December 6, 2025.

Our View: In this case, the Panel deemed a registration prohibition order necessary due to the severity and complexity of Mr. Rogers’ contraventions. The media release (23-335MR) provided further details on the Panel’s decision, emphasising the importance of prioritising client interests and providing appropriate advice.

14. 23/01/2024 – Mr A

Alleged Misconduct: The Panel found that Mr A contravened sections 961B(1), 961G, 961J(1), 921E(3), and 1041E(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 in respect of superannuation switching advice provided to two clients. Specifically, he needed to adequately consider his client’s objectives, needs, and financial situations, provided inappropriate advice, prioritised his interests over the clients’, and included misleading information in the SOAs. The provider received (undisclosed) soft dollar benefits from the fund, misrepresented performance data and recommended ongoing service that was unnecessary given the clients’ circumstances.

Panel’s Decision: A written direction was issued under section 921L(1)(a)(iii) of the Corporations Act 2001, requiring Mr A to engage an independent person to pre-vet and audit his following 20 recommendations (10 insurance and ten superannuation recommendations). The independent expert’s recommendations must be acknowledged and formally responded to by the adviser’s Licensee, and any deviation must be reported to ASIC.

Our View: While Mr A’s conduct was deemed serious, the Panel opted for a targeted remedial approach rather than an outright ban. This decision reflects the Panel’s commitment to upholding professional standards while allowing advisers to improve their practices under close supervision. It is also consistent with the Panel’s approach of differentiating between process and conduct issues and trying to remediate process issues before taking administrative action. Again, the engagement of the independent expert is the adviser’s responsibility, and this approach effectively reinforces an adviser’s personal accountability for their advice and advice processes.

15. 26/02/2024 – Mr B

Alleged Misconduct: The matter was referred to the Panel due to concerns that Mr B contravened sections 961B(1) and 961G of the Corporations Act 2001 by failing to demonstrate the benefits of a more expensive recommended product and failing to show that the client’s existing funds could not meet their investment preferences.

Panel’s Decision: No action was taken against Mr. B.

Our View: Based on the SOA provided, the Panel was not satisfied that Mr. B had contravened the Corporations Act 2001. The decision may have been influenced by the fact that the additional cost was not material ($1960 pa) and did not materially affect the client’s interests. It may also confirm that the FSCP takes a more flexible, risk-based approach to compliance issues that may, over time, be more widely adopted. It may signal the start of a regulatory shift away from the “tick a box” approach to compliance, an approach so strongly criticised by Commissioner Hayne but so beloved by compliance “experts”.

16. 07/03/2024 – Ms G

Alleged Misconduct: The Panel determined that Ms G contravened sections 946A(1) and 921E(3) of the Corporations Act 2001 by failing to provide Statements of Advice (SOAs) to five retail clients between June 2022 and August 2022. In doing so, she failed to demonstrate the Code of Ethics’ values of competence and diligence and breached Standard 1 of the Code.

Panel’s Decision: A reprimand was issued under section 921T(1) of the Corporations Act 2001.

Our View: While the failure to provide SOAs is a significant breach, the Panel likely considered Ms G’s specific circumstances and the nature of the contraventions. However, given the number of contraventions and their significant impact, the Panel may have thought that an independent review would not be a reasonable or appropriate response. On the other hand, a reprimand serves as a formal warning and reminder of the adviser’s obligations while allowing them to rectify their conduct and comply with the requirements moving forward.

Why were no Licensees subject to further action?

You may review these decisions and wonder why the FSCP focuses on individual advisers’ misconduct but ignores the Licensee’s role in these failures.

ASIC Regulatory Guide 263 confirms that the FSCP has the authority to take a range of actions in response to alleged misconduct. They can mandate specific training, counselling, supervision, or reporting. The Panel can also suspend, ban, and reprimand advisers and refer matters to ASIC. However, it’s important to understand that the Panel can only consider and make decisions on matters that pertain to a ‘relevant provider’.

In simple terms, a relevant provider (defined in s910A of the Corporations Act) is an individual who is an Australian financial services (AFS) licensee, an employee or director of an AFS Licensee or a related body corporate, or an authorised representative authorised to provide personal financial product advice to retail clients. 

However, this doesn’t entirely explain why licensees were not subject to further ASIC action in these cases. The FSCP may not have the authority to investigate or monitor Licensees, but ASIC does. So why are no complementary media releases focusing on the Licensees or their compliance arrangements? 

There could be several potential reasons:

∙ Licensees’ Remedial Actions: In some cases, ASIC may have considered the remedial actions taken by licensees to address the advisers’ misconduct, such as implementing additional training, supervision, or compliance measures.  If the licensee’s response to an adviser’s misconduct was deemed adequate and effective, ASIC may have decided that investigation or further action against the licensee was unnecessary.

∙ Isolated Incidents: If the adviser’s misconduct appeared to be an isolated incident or a one-off failure rather than a systemic issue, ASIC might have determined that the licensee’s existing compliance framework and supervision were generally sufficient and that further action was unnecessary.

∙ Proportionality: ASIC may have considered the proportionality of taking action against the licensees, weighing the severity of the adviser’s misconduct against the potential impact on the licensee’s business operations and other advisers within the firm who were not involved in the misconduct.

∙ Responsibility and Accountability: The Panel focuses on holding individual advisers accountable for their actions and ensuring they meet professional standards. While licensees have a responsibility to supervise and monitor their advisers, the Panel (and ASIC) may have determined that the adviser’s misconduct was primarily attributable to the adviser’s actions and decisions rather than failures on the part of the licensee.

∙ Insufficient Evidence: In some cases, there may need to be more evidence to establish that the licensee failed in its supervisory or compliance obligations, even if an adviser engaged in misconduct, and there may be no compelling reason to investigate further.

∙ Ongoing Monitoring and Supervision: Rather than offering explicit criticism of a licensee, the Panel may have relied on ASIC’s ongoing monitoring and supervision of licensees to ensure they address deficiencies in the Licensee’s compliance frameworks and adviser oversight processes. Or, perhaps the Licensee is already subject to a specific ASIC investigation. The Panel’s tendency to require independent experts to report to ASIC suggests that FSCP determinations will influence ASIC’s ongoing monitoring activities. 

It’s important to note that the absence of public action against licensees in these specific cases does not necessarily mean that licensees are never held accountable. In cases with clear evidence of systemic failures, inadequate supervision, or a lack of appropriate policies and procedures, licensees may face regulatory action, such as license conditions, enforceable undertakings, or even license suspensions or cancellations. Still, it’s unrealistic to expect simultaneous determinations. The Panel’s approach to licensee accountability likely depends on the specific circumstances of each case.

Conclusion:

Although some commentators criticise the FSCP for their inconsistencies, a more considered assessment might lead one to the realisation that the FSCP considers matters in context and takes a risk-based approach to compliance failures. This nuanced and considered approach might not satisfy those looking for programmatic certainty. Still, it should reassure advisers and licensees that the FSCP is fair, reasonable and eminently capable of identifying the real causes of advice failures and determining appropriate responses. 

Although the clarity of its decisions has improved over time, the Panel’s flexible approach remains predictable, consistent, and reassuring. The FSCP focuses on evidence, considers cause, materiality, and impact, and tailors appropriate regulatory responses.

Summary:

Cases where the FSCP recommended the adviser’s files be reviewed by an external party (43.75%):

  1. 29/05/2023 – Mr S. The FSCP issued an instrument under s921L(1)(a)(iii) directing that Mr S provide ASIC with the reports of three successive compliance audits undertaken by his Licensee.
  2. 20/06/2023 – Mr M. The FSCP issued an instrument under s921L(1)(a)(iii) directing that Mr M engage an independent person with expertise in financial services laws compliance to pre-vet and audit 20 SOAs that Mr M intends to present to a retail client. This was due to concerns over Mr M’s compliance with best interests duty and other obligations.
  3. 26/07/2023 – Mr X. The FSCP issued a written direction under section 921L(1)(a)(iii) of the Corporations Act 2001, requiring Mr X to engage, at his own cost, an independent person to audit 20 SOAs (10 related to insurance and ten related to superannuation) and report back to ASIC. The independent expert’s recommendations must be acknowledged and formally responded to by the adviser’s Licensee, and any deviation must be reported to ASIC.
  4. 31/08/2023 – Mr O. A written direction was issued by the FSCP under section 921L(1)(a)(iii) of the Corporations Act 2001, requiring Mr O to engage, at his own cost, an independent person to audit 10 SOAs and report back to ASIC.
  5. 31/08/2023 – Mr H. The FSCP issued a written direction under section 921L(1)(a)(iii) of the Corporations Act 2001, requiring Mr H to engage, at his own cost, an independent person to audit 10 SOAs and report back to ASIC.
  6. 08/09/2023 – Ms D. The FSCP issued an instrument under s921L(1)(a)(iii) directing that Ms D engage an independent person to pre-vet her following 10 Statements of Advice (SOAs) to retail clients. This was due to concerns that Ms D had failed to act in her client’s best interests by not properly considering their relevant circumstances when providing advice.
  7. 23/01/2024 – Mr A: The FSCP issued an instrument under s921L(1)(a)(iii) directing that Mr A engage an independent person to pre-vet and audit his next 10 SOAs with insurance recommendations and next 10 SOAs with superannuation recommendations to retail clients. This was because the FSCP found Mr A had provided inappropriate advice that did not adequately consider the clients’ objectives and situations.

Cases where the FSCP took no action (18.75%):

  1. 12/09/2023 – Mr V
  2. 11/10/2023 – Mr P
  3. 26/02/2024 – Mr B

In these cases, the FSCP did not find sufficient evidence of breaches of advisers’ obligations.

Cases where the FSCP recommended administrative action against the adviser (37.5%):

  1. 07/08/2023 – Mr K. Reprimand for failing to meet advice standards and obligations.
  2. 10/08/2023 – Mr E. Reprimand for failing to meet advice standards and obligations. A reprimand was issued under s921T(1) for providing inappropriate advice without adequate justification.
  3. 29/09/2023 – Mr T. Written warning for failing to meet advice standards and obligations. A warning was issued under s921T(1)(b) for failing to comply with the best interests duty and other obligations.
  4. 01/12/2023 – Mr Stephen Rogers: Written order prohibiting his registration until after 6 December 2025 under s921K(1)(a) and s921L(1)(c) due to serious breaches.
  5. 04/12/2023 – Mr Timothy Anderson: Written order cancelling his registration until after 17 May 2025 under s921K(1)(a) and s921L(1)(c) due to breaches.
  6. 07/03/2024 – Ms G. Reprimand issued under s921T(1) for failing to provide SOAs as required.

Keep exploring

Subscribe

Every fortnight “Three Hit Tuesday” delivers thought leadership, considered analysis and insights that will help you improve your advice, more effectively manage your regulatory risks and make you better informed than your peers.

AS-Subscribe Form

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We respect your privacy. We know everyone says that, but we promise that we won’t sell your contact details to dodgy telemarketers, spam your email or otherwise exploit your trust.

Step 1 of 8 - Your Role

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Assess your ASIC exposure

Answer a few targeted questions to identify where your compliance may not stand up under ASIC review.

Takes less than 2 minutes. No preparation required.

What best describes your role?