Documenting the strategy and selection process.

Documenting the Strategy and Product Selection Process.

I’m so dizzy my head is spinning

Like a whirlpool, it never ends

And it’s you, product replacement requirements, making it spin

You’re making me dizzy

– Tommy Roe (or an adviser providing advice to replace an existing product)

Tommy Roe, Dizzy (youtube.com)

 

Ask any adviser, and they’ll tell you there is no shortage of product options out there. 

So many, in fact, that one may understandably fall into a state of paralysis from analysis. 

Even without the Design and Distribution regime adding to the complexity of the situation, it can be challenging for advisers to manage their obligations in the pursuit of better outcomes for their clients.

A good adviser will always prioritise strategies and see the product as a tactical solution to their client’s increasingly complex needs, but the product itself does play an important role none-the-less. Historically, this part of the advice process has been an ongoing battle and a key area of focus for advisers; even those who generally nail the other aspects of their advice process. 

We enjoy throwing topics up for discussion and our help email (help@assuredsupport.com.au) usually has plenty for us. 

Sometimes our perspectives and preferences diverge, and while we rarely come to blows, the debate can be robust. In this article, two of our Compliancers® go head-to-head exploring the topic of replacement product advice. 

In the red corner, we have Manny ‘Maestro of Mayhem’ Kazoullis (“The Maestro” 21-3-0), and in the blue corner, we have ‘The B-52 Bomber’ Ben Moffatt (“The Bomber” 26-0-0). 

With over 36 years combined experience, and with both in their prime, it’s unlikely to end in a No-contest. They’re prepared, they’ve trained hard and it’s anyone’s guess who’ll come out on top. 

ROUND 1 

Identifying and prioritising needs, objectives, and preferences

Manny ‘Maestro of Mayhem’ Kazoullis:

When financial planners are identifying and prioritising the needs, objectives, and preferences of their clients, their process needs to be methodical (and documented). This process should always include an initial assessment of the client’s financial situation. Advisers need to meet the Best Interest Duty and FASEA Standards when providing retail advice, and this all begins with identifying the objectives, financial situation, and needs of the client. 

During this operation, the adviser needs to gather (relevant) and detailed information about the client and discuss the client’s short-term and long-term financial goals. These may include retirement planning, saving for education, buying a home, or wealth accumulation. 

As we all know, if this isn’t done well, we may end up with competing objectives that aren’t addressed properly, and inappropriate advice which doesn’t satisfy critical client needs. 

Once the objectives and scope of the advice have been identified (and agreed to), the adviser needs to assess investment risk understanding and tolerance, as well as the investment time horizon and any liquidity needs, since these may also influence the advice path. 

These inquiries will allow the adviser to uncover the client’s preference for investment strategies, and discussions may include active management versus passive indexing, growth-oriented versus income-focused investments, or sector-specific versus diversified portfolios. It is presumed that these discussions will include some education where required, depending on client knowledge. 

An adviser needs to ask themselves whether the client’s understanding of investing may limit the strategies and products available. Some clients may have a high level of familiarity with certain types of investments, whereas others may not. A thorough discussion to gather detailed information will establish the client’s level of knowledge, and ensure that the strategies and products considered are appropriate. 

Determining the client’s level of involvement is also important. Options available may vary greatly depending on whether or not the client would like to approve every decision made about the portfolio. If so, recommending a portfolio that delegates decisions to a third party may not be appropriate. 

We’d also suggest discussing the client’s current investment holdings and their satisfaction level with the performance, risk profile, and suitability of these investments. Identify any specific concerns or preferences the client has regarding their existing portfolio, such as diversification, cost-effectiveness, or alignment with personal values.

Ask specific questions about their comfort level with fees and charges, their perception of value for money, and any concerns they have regarding cost-effectiveness. Inquire whether they prefer a simple and transparent fee structure or are willing to pay higher fees for additional features or services.

Lastly, we would also recommend determining whether the client has an interest in ethical, environmental, or social considerations that may influence their investment preferences.

‘The B-52 Bomber’ Ben Moffatt:

As Manny has pointed out, subject matter and scoping are vitally important in the advice process, and ASIC has a very clear view of the effect this has on the client when it isn’t executed properly. Report 639 may be a little dated (2019), but it is still relevant and contains several gems concerning what ASIC is looking for when assessing advice. 

The report considered 233 advice files from 21 different Licensees and highlighted subject matter failures that ultimately led to more than 50% of the advice being not in the client’s best interest. Basically, if an adviser doesn’t identify the subject matter in the beginning, the advice can’t be appropriately scoped, and consequently, will not be in the client’s best interest. 

Manny is right in that the client’s needs, objectives and preferences need to be identified and considered as part of the Best Interest Duty ((s961B)(2)) and FASEA Standards, and the prioritisation of the objectives and needs should be documented clearly – especially when they conflict with one another. 

What we also need to see is that the adviser isn’t overloading the client with irrelevant information, or recording scope and objectives that aligns to their own preferences, rather than the client’s. For example, recording preferences that weren’t discussed, but coincidentally align to an in-house product. 

Everything Manny has highlighted needs to be considered by the adviser, and I think the documentation of this process may vary from client to client, and elements can be recorded through the initial discussions, alternatives and other considerations.

For example, a client with little or no investment experience may have simpler objectives and needs than an experienced investor, so the process of prioritising the client’s objectives may be shorter due to fewer conflicts in the objectives themselves. We always recommend that the client’s objectives are recorded in their own words, and depending on the client’s level of experience, this may require education to be provided during the process, or different types of questions to be asked. 

ROUND 2:

Product selection process

The Bomber:

At the risk of flogging a dead horse, we may refer to s961B(2) “The Safe Harbour Steps” when considering the appropriateness of product replacement advice, but we don’t think it’s the only way to promote quality advice in isolation. Generally, a checklist approach rarely works in isolation, although it may be of use as part of a considered process when constructing (and assessing) advice. 

Before making any recommendations to replace existing products, s961B(2)(e) requires the adviser (who is acting in their client’s best interest) to:

(i) Conduct a reasonable investigation into the financial products that might achieve the objectives and meet the needs of the client that would reasonably be considered as relevant to advice on that subject matter: and

(ii) Assess the information gathered in the investigation.

Advisers will also need to “base all judgements in advising the client on the client’s relevant circumstances” and “take any additional step that….would reasonably be regarded as being in the best interests of the client” as it is a part of the adviser’s professional duty, but ‘reasonable’ may vary client to client. 

Despite some views on the industry, it is rare to see advisers routinely adopt a “one-size-fits-all” approach, although that’s not to say we don’t see it sometimes. But, for many reasons, advisers do sometimes struggle to find a research methodology that reconciles commercial realities with their aspirations and external expectations. This is, in some respects, both surprising and depressing. After all, this has always been a core obligation for advice professionals. 

Another key component is assessing the information collected (including the relevant TMDs). 

The first step (as Manny has pointed out) is to figure out what a client wants and consider this in conjunction with their relevant circumstances. This will give anchor points to tie the advice to, and when done well, it offers a great platform for the advice.  

Conversely, it is a road fraught with danger when the same solution is offered to all clients, regardless of their objectives and circumstances, or when the objectives haven’t been uncovered and documented initially. 

In our view, the best advisers have a robust process that is led by the client’s objectives, and the level of their inquiries is based on their own professional judgement (which is hard to evidence when the file is incomplete). 

As form follows function, product should follow strategy. 

The Maestro:

Agreed, it can be overwhelming, but it doesn’t have to be. Rather than seeing the plethora of product options as a source of paralysis, advisers can also view it as an opportunity to customise their recommendations to meet each client’s unique needs. Drilling down to identify the client’s objectives, investment preferences and priorities will go a long way to support the recommendations.

The strategy and product selection process should be based on an in-depth understanding of the client’s objectives, preferences and priorities. Documenting this process is vital, as it can assist with evidencing a client-centric (and not product-driven) approach. 

This process involves more than just listing potential options; it requires a detailed assessment of how each product was considered to meet the client’s specific requirements. The best advisers understand that a one-size-fits-all approach is inadequate. Each client’s needs and circumstances are unique, and the advice provided should reflect this. 

We’re not saying that every product needs to be considered, but the process needs to have a method behind it, and the products considered should be consistent with objectives and needs. 

For example, when recommending an in-house SMA, the adviser cannot just rely on the fact that the Licensee has conducted research at the Investment Committee level. This would not satisfy Best Interest Duty, as the adviser needs to conduct their own independent investigation into “financial products that might achieve those of the objectives and meet those of the needs of the client” and evidence that they have “assessed the information gathered in the process.” 

It also becomes a little trickier when additional benefits are being received from the products. While the adviser may not benefit from this (directly) this potential conflict needs to be managed. If other products which are similar in nature haven’t been considered, this may be difficult. 

Generally speaking, the adviser doesn’t have to consider a traditional managed fund, ETF, SMA, MDA, bespoke portfolio, and everything in between every single time. They just need to make sure the product they’re considering has the features and options that are likely to satisfy the client’s objectives, needs and preferences. Ensuring the relevant TMDs are carefully considered and documented also plays a part in the process. 

At a minimum, we would suggest considering the following:

  1. The current product (as is and with changes).
  2. An alternate, but not recommended, product.
  3. The new and recommended product.

This isn’t to say this is all that should be done. Simply listing options considered still lacks the assessment element. As a general rule, meeting more complex client needs may require more investigation. Rather than setting the standard at meeting the minimum, we’d suggest investigating as many options as required for the client. 

ROUND 3

Explaining the advice

The Maestro:

We’ve established that when making a product replacement recommendation, it’s crucial for financial advisers to ensure that the new product aligns with the client’s needs, objectives, and priorities, and to ensure there is sufficient research to support the product replacement. What comes after this – and is sometimes left to generic, boilerplate text – is to explain what is being done and why. 

The majority of the SOAs we see day-to-day adequately explain the advice, but, unfortunately, there are still some that need to be closely examined to find the specific reasoning as to why an existing product is being replaced, or a product is being introduced. 

Aside from being a legal requirement, the SOA is an opportunity to explain to the client the value of the services and advice being provided and to show the client how they are going to be in a better position. 

The SOA needs to explain how the replacement product addresses the client’s specific needs. The explanations must highlight any features or benefits of the new product that directly meet the client’s requirements and demonstrate why the existing product isn’t doing this (well, or at all). 

Explanations need to address how the replacement product aligns with the client’s investment objectives and long-term financial goals, and how the new product’s investment strategy, risk profile, and performance potential are consistent with the client’s desired outcomes and objectives. 

A direct link needs to be made between the client’s key investment preferences, priorities (such as cost-effectiveness, transparency or ethical positions) and the product itself. Highlight any benefits and advantages of the new product, such as the lower fees, improved (potential) investment performance, features, or quality of service. 

The advice cannot rely upon assumptions or reasonings that are vague in nature, and supporting documents are just that – supporting documents. These shouldn’t be relied upon to explain advice. The SOA needs to stand alone.  

By explaining how the product replacement recommendation meets the client’s needs, objectives, and priorities, financial advisers can help clients make informed decisions that support their long-term financial success. This transparent and client-centric approach fosters trust and strengthens the adviser-client relationship. 

‘The Bomber’:

How can we possibly put all of that in an SOA, as well as the costs and implications of the advice? Well, there are a couple of options that can be used in isolation, or, a complimentary fashion, depending on needs: 

  1. Use a smaller font and use both sides of the paper. 
  2. Do away with punctuation. 
  3. Incorporation by reference. 
  4. Replace generic explanations with personalised text that is derived from a sound discovery process, which includes a thorough examination of circumstances, needs, and objectives, supporting documents and fantastic file notes.

S947D of the Corporations Act outlines the requirements when replacing a product. Admittedly, s947D is primarily associated with the costs and implications of doing so, but without the ‘why’, we are simply left with factual information, such as costs, loss of benefits (to the client), and benefits received (by an entity) for providing the advice. 

S947B(6) requires the information in the SOA to be worded and presented in a clear, concise and effective form, and (S12DA) prohibits misleading and deceptive conduct. If the advice isn’t explained, it could be seen as an attempt to mislead (especially if additional costs and benefits are being received by other parties). 

For some context, ASIC’s view is that appropriateness is an advice quality measure determined by likely outcomes and consequences. Best Interest Duty is mostly associated with process and adherence is based on whether the client is likely to be in a better position.

If the advice document doesn’t clearly and effectively link the recommendations to the client’s circumstances, objectives, and needs, then it is very difficult to assess the outcome and whether the client will be in a better position. 

The law does not require the cheapest product to be recommended every time, nor does it state that only products that provide no benefit to anyone except the client can be recommended. However, advice needs to be provided in a manner that is likely to be understood by the client. 

Relying on cookie-cutter explanations, vague comments, and reasons that are not client-centric or based on the client’s objectives will lead to inappropriate advice. If the advice is not clear, concise, and effective, then it is difficult to confirm that the client understands the advice. This will also lead to issues with the FASEA Standards as well. 

Read: Five advice failures (and their simple fixes)

Keep exploring

Subscribe

Every fortnight “Three Hit Tuesday” delivers thought leadership, considered analysis and insights that will help you improve your advice, more effectively manage your regulatory risks and make you better informed than your peers.

AS-Subscribe Form

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We respect your privacy. We know everyone says that, but we promise that we won’t sell your contact details to dodgy telemarketers, spam your email or otherwise exploit your trust.

Step 1 of 8 - Your Role

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Assess your ASIC exposure

Answer a few targeted questions to identify where your compliance may not stand up under ASIC review.

Takes less than 2 minutes. No preparation required.

What best describes your role?