From Risk Registers to Real Controls: A Practical Guide for AFSLs and ACLs

The most marked difference between compliance and risk management is that compliance generally asks “how did it end?” while risks wonders “where could this go?”

Professionals ponder both questions regularly. 

Those who do understand that the next systemic issue is unlikely to announce itself as a legal problem. It’s more likely to start as a missed exception report, a system configuration error, an ageing complaint, an outsourced process no one is really monitoring, or a vulnerability flag that doesn’t travel across the business or trigger formal alerts in rigid systems. AFCA’s Systemic Issues Insights Report, Edition 8, covering quarters 1 and 2 of the 2025–26 financial year, captures the point plainly: “formal frameworks alone are not sufficient”. For advisers, AFSLs and ACLs, that should be the catalyst to reframe risk management from documentation to evidence.

The reality is that financial services businesses are already operating in a risk environment that is more connected, more technology-dependent and more conduct-sensitive than in previous years. 2026-2027 will only solidify that trend. In fact, global risk outlooks from Forvis Mazars and Protiviti point to the same broad risk patterns becoming increasingly relevant. Cyber resilience, third-party dependency, AI adoption, operational resilience, regulatory change, financial crime, customer trust and economic pressure are no longer separate risk issues; they are complementary and compounding.

Practically, this means that advisers, AFSLs and ACLs, should rely less on larger compliance manuals and disconnected uplift projects, and instead prioritise simplifying operating models, improving evidence, testing critical controls and showing that their risk management arrangements are focused on client outcomes.

Recent financial services risk analysis supports this direction. Protiviti’s 2026 financial services perspectives identify simplification, technology enablement, cyber threats, third-party risk, AI implementation risk, workforce upskilling and economic conditions as leading near-term themes. Forvis Mazars similarly identifies cyber, operational resilience, outsourcing, AI adoption, financial crime, geopolitical and macroeconomic volatility, and regulatory pressure as priority risks for financial services firms.

The critical point for advisers, AFSLs and ACLs is that these themes reflect regulatory expectations. s912A(1)(h) of the Corporations Act embeds risk management as a core obligation for AFSL, as important as the obligations to provide financial services efficiently, honestly and fairly, comply with financial services laws, maintain competence, supervise representatives and have adequate resources.

Poor cyber controls, weak AI governance, inadequate oversight of service providers, ineffective complaints handling, misleading pricing, deficient hardship practices, and poor product due diligence are governance, conduct, operational, privacy, financial crime, and client-harm issues, with real consequences where Licensees can’t demonstrate effective systems, controls, and supervision.

For many licensees, the challenge is no longer identifying risks. It is demonstrating that controls operate consistently and that emerging issues are escalated before they become client harm events.


The risk environment has changed

Instead of a series of distinct threats, it’s critical to recognise that the 2026–2027 risk environment is an interconnected system.

A cyber incident can become a privacy breach, an outsourcing failure, a spike in complaints, and a breach-reporting issue. Poorly governed AI initiatives can create defective client records, misleading communications, unsuitable advice, biased credit processes or inadequate complaint triage. A third-party platform failure can affect service continuity, client access, data integrity and responsible manager oversight. A weak due diligence process can expose clients to inappropriate private credit, illiquid products or conflicted distribution arrangements.

That is why the dominant theme for 2026–2027 is the convergence of risk. The firms best placed are those that can demonstrate that their governance, technology, compliance, and client-facing processes work together.


ASIC’s current enforcement priorities localise the global risk themes

ASIC’s 2026 enforcement priorities give a clear local signal for Australian licensees as they plan for the 2026–2027 risk environment. ASIC has named private credit practices, financial reporting misconduct, insurance complaints and claims handling, misleading pricing, misconduct exploiting consumers facing financial difficulty, and continuing work connected to the Shield and First Guardian collapses as priority areas. ASIC’s AFSL guidance also expressly states that AFS licensees must have adequate risk management systems in place.

For advisers and AFSLs, this means greater scrutiny of product selection, due diligence, conflicts, private credit exposure, target market alignment, reliance on research, and client communications. For ACLs, the relevance is equally direct: hardship, financial difficulty, misleading pricing, vulnerable borrowers, broker oversight and complaint handling should be treated as board and senior management issues, not back-office administration.

ASIC’s priorities also show that enforcement risk is increasingly connected to consumer harm. A technically compliant process will not be enough if the practical outcome is poor, unfair, misleading or inadequately supervised.


AI governance needs to move from informal use to controlled use

AI is now part of the operating environment for advice and credit businesses. It may already be used for file notes, SOA and ROA drafting, research summaries, marketing content, client segmentation, fraud detection, complaint classification, workflow automation, credit scenarios, meeting preparation or quality assurance.

ASIC’s Report 798, Beware the gap: Governance arrangements in the face of AI innovation, makes AI a live issue for both AFSLs and ACLs. ASIC’s review considered how 23 AFS and credit licensees were using, or planning to use, AI and how they were identifying, governing and mitigating associated consumer risks. The practical control expectation is straightforward. You should know what AI tools are being used, who is using them, what client information is entered, what outputs are relied on, what human review is required and how errors are escalated. An AI tool should not become an undocumented shadow system.

A sensible 2026–2027 uplift would include an AI register; approved and prohibited use cases; client data restrictions; human review standards; vendor due diligence; record-keeping rules; monitoring for hallucinations and bias; and clear escalation triggers when AI output may have affected a client outcome.

Licensees should also periodically test whether staff are using unapproved AI tools outside approved workflows, as shadow AI creates governance, privacy and record-keeping risks.


Cyber resilience is now a governance, privacy and client-trust issue

Cyber risk is not just an IT issue. For advisers, AFSLs and ACLs, it is a client protection issue. Client files, identification documents, financial information, health information, bank details, loan data, tax information and investment records are high-value targets.

Global risk outlooks identify cyber as a top financial services risk, and local cyber guidance provides a practical baseline for uplift. The Australian Signals Directorate’s Essential Eight provides a recognised Australian cyber baseline, while the OAIC’s Notifiable Data Breaches reporting provides evidence of the ongoing privacy and data-breach exposure facing Australian entities. For smaller and mid-sized firms, the question should be practical: do you have multi-factor authentication, secure backups, patching discipline, access controls, phishing resilience, device controls, incident response procedures and supplier cyber oversight? More importantly, can you provide evidence that those controls are operating?


Operational resilience and outsourcing need more discipline

Modern advice and credit firms are deeply dependent on third parties. CRMs, research providers, platforms, licensee systems, aggregator systems, lender portals, document automation tools, paraplanning providers, compliance consultants, offshore support, cyber vendors, lead generators and referral partners can all affect client outcomes.

APRA’s CPS 230 applies to APRA-regulated entities and is highly relevant as a benchmark. CPS 230 is designed to ensure APRA-regulated entities manage operational risks, maintain critical operations through disruptions and manage risks arising from service providers. For non-APRA AFSLs and ACLs, CPS 230 should not be overstated as a direct legal obligation unless the firm is APRA-regulated or contractually brought into scope. However, its logic is useful: identify critical operations, set tolerances, test severe but plausible disruptions, understand material service providers and plan for failure.

A supplier register is not enough. You should know which providers are critical, what would happen if they failed, what client harm could occur, what workarounds exist, who would communicate with clients, and how quickly the business could recover.


AML/CTF reform should be treated as a 2026–2027 implementation project

Financial crime and fraud are now central to the risk environment. Generative AI, synthetic identity, scams, cyber-enabled fraud and complex investment structures increase the exposure for advice and credit firms.

Australia’s AML/CTF reforms and 2026 transitional arrangements mean advisers should not assume AML/CTF is only a banking or casino issue. AUSTRAC has published transitional guidance explaining that some reporting entities will have more time to update their systems, processes, and AML/CTF programs, with arrangements varying depending on the enrolment date and designated services. For advisers and AFSLs, the forward-looking preparation task is to assess whether services, client types, referral channels or product exposures create AML/CTF obligations or practical financial crime risks. For ACLs, the same applies to identity verification, suspicious activity, broker-originated applications, document fraud, hardship fraud, mule accounts and scam-related lending.

The practical uplift should include a financial crime risk assessment, a customer due diligence process, an escalation pathway for suspicious matters, staff training, AML/CTF compliance officer planning, where relevant, and independent review arrangements.


Complaints, hardship and vulnerable clients should be treated as risk indicators

AFCA complaint trends show that complaints remain a material issue across the financial services system. AFCA reported that complaints remained above 100,000 in 2024–25 for the second year in a row, reinforcing the need to treat complaints as risk intelligence rather than administrative closure work. For AFSLs and ACLs, complaints are not just an IDR function. They are an early warning system. Repeated complaints about delays, unclear fees, unsuitable recommendations, poor communication, hardship treatment, claims handling, refinancing, platform issues or adviser conduct should trigger root-cause analysis.

ASIC’s focus on consumers facing financial difficulty makes this especially important for ACLs. Hardship handling, responsible lending, broker conduct, vulnerable borrower treatment and collection practices should be tested as part of compliance monitoring. For AFSLs, vulnerability may arise through age, cognitive decline, bereavement, family violence, disability, financial stress, low financial literacy or exposure to scams.

The better question is not “Did you respond within the timeframe?” It is “What did the complaint reveal about the way the business operates?”


Private credit and product governance require sharper due diligence

Private credit warrants specific focus in the 2026–2027 risk environment because ASIC has identified it as an enforcement priority. The continuing regulatory attention on Shield and First Guardian also reinforces the need for sharper product due diligence, platform governance, adviser supervision and client communication. The Shield and First Guardian matters also reinforce the need for careful due diligence across product approval, platform availability, adviser recommendations, research reliance, liquidity assessment and client communication.

For AFSLs, this means product governance should not be reduced to checking whether a product has a disclosure document or target market determination. You should understand the investment structure, liquidity, valuation methodology, leverage, related-party exposure, fees, conflicts, redemption terms, borrower concentration and stress scenarios.

For advisers, the practical question is whether the client understands the risk they are taking, especially where the product is described as income-focused, defensive, capital stable or suitable for retirees. Private credit can be appropriate in some circumstances, but it should not be treated as a simple substitute for cash, term deposits or traditional fixed income.


What you should do in the next 90 days

The most useful 2026–2027 uplift is a focused control review across the areas most likely to create client harm.

Start with your risk register. Update it so cyber, AI, outsourcing, financial crime, complaints, hardship, vulnerable clients, private credit, misleading pricing and product governance are not treated as separate compliance themes. Identify which risks share common controls and which controls are currently unsupported by evidence.

Then review your critical processes. For AFSLs, this should include client onboarding, advice production, product approval, file review, complaints, breach reporting, high-risk product advice, vulnerable client handling and ongoing service delivery. For ACLs, this should include lead generation, credit assessment, pricing, broker oversight, hardship, complaints, refinancing, fraud controls and vulnerable borrower treatment.

Next, test your evidence. Can you show that cyber controls operate, AI outputs are reviewed, suppliers are assessed, complaints are analysed, hardship requests are handled properly and product due diligence is current? If the answer is unclear, the control is probably weaker than it appears.

Finally, simplify. Remove duplicated registers, unclear policies and control steps that no one owns. Replace them with practical workflows, clear escalation points, accountable owners and regular reporting to senior management or the board.


Key questions for boards, responsible managers and senior leaders

You should be able to answer these questions confidently:

  • Can you identify your most critical client-facing processes and the systems or providers they depend on?
  • Can you explain how AI is used in your business, what is prohibited and how outputs are checked?
  • Can you show that cyber controls are tested, not just documented?
  • Can you identify your highest-risk products, referral sources, client segments and third-party providers?
  • Can you prove that complaints, hardship requests and vulnerable client matters are reviewed for systemic issues?
  • Can you demonstrate that private credit or other complex products receive proportionate due diligence before being recommended or distributed?
  • Can you show how client harm indicators are escalated to responsible managers, senior management or the board?

Bottom line

The 2026–2027 risk environment rewards firms that can show control in practice. For advisers, AFSLs and ACLs, the priority is not to produce more policy documents. It is to simplify operations, strengthen governance over technology and third parties, improve evidence, and connect compliance activity to client outcomes.

A strong 2026–2027 risk program should make it easier to answer one question: if ASIC, AFCA, a lender, a professional indemnity insurer or a client asked how you knew your systems were working, could you prove it?

Related content

ASIC governance imperatives for 2026

Risk management 2.0: the evolution of risk management in Australian financial services

The hidden risks of AI: ASIC’s review of licensees’ embrace of artificial intelligence


Frequently Asked Questions

Is risk management a legal obligation for AFSL holders?

Yes. Risk management is not simply a governance best practice; it is a statutory obligation. Section 912A(1)(h) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) requires AFS licensees to maintain adequate risk management systems.

Importantly, ASIC does not view risk management as a standalone document or annual exercise. It expects licensees to identify material risks, implement controls, monitor effectiveness, and respond when weaknesses emerge. This includes operational risks, cyber risks, complaints trends, outsourcing arrangements, product governance issues and emerging technology risks such as AI.

The practical question for a licensee is not whether a risk framework exists, but whether it can demonstrate that controls are operating effectively and reducing the likelihood of client harm.

What are the biggest risks facing AFSLs and ACLs in 2026–2027?

The most significant risks are increasingly interconnected rather than isolated. Cyber incidents can trigger privacy breaches, service disruptions, complaints and regulatory reporting obligations. Poor AI governance can affect advice quality, credit decisions, record keeping and customer communications.

Weak oversight of service providers can create operational resilience issues and client detriment.
Regulators are also focusing on private credit, financial difficulty, misleading pricing, complaints handling and vulnerable consumers. At the same time, AML/CTF reforms and evolving financial crime threats are increasing expectations around customer due diligence and monitoring.

Rather than treating these as separate compliance topics, firms should assess how risks interact and whether common controls are adequately designed, tested and evidenced.

Why should complaints be treated as a risk management tool rather than an administrative process?

Complaints often reveal operational weaknesses before they become reportable breaches, AFCA disputes, remediation programs or regulatory investigations.

A complaint about delayed service may indicate a resource issue. Repeated complaints about fees, advice quality, hardship treatment or communication failures may point to broader governance, training or supervision problems. In that sense, complaints are one of the most valuable sources of risk intelligence available to a business.

High-performing licensees do more than close complaints within required timeframes. They analyse trends, identify root causes and assess whether recurring issues indicate systemic weaknesses. The question should not simply be whether the complaint was resolved, but what the complaint revealed about how the business operates.

What evidence should a licensee maintain to demonstrate effective risk management?

Policies alone are rarely sufficient. Regulators, auditors, professional indemnity insurers and external dispute bodies increasingly want evidence that controls operate in practice.

Examples may include cyber testing reports, supplier reviews, AI governance records, breach assessments, complaints analysis, due diligence files, control attestations, management reports, training records and board or committee minutes. Evidence should demonstrate not only that a control exists but that it is monitored, reviewed and updated when issues arise.

A useful test is this: if ASIC, AFCA or an auditor asked how you knew a critical control was working, could you produce evidence immediately? If not, the control may be less robust than it appears.

Does CPS 230 apply to all AFSLs and ACLs?

No. CPS 230 is a prudential standard that applies directly to APRA-regulated entities and should not be described as a legal obligation for most AFSLs or ACLs.

However, its operational resilience principles provide a useful benchmark for all financial services businesses. CPS 230 focuses on identifying critical operations, understanding dependencies, managing service-provider risk and preparing for disruption.

Even where the standard does not legally apply, the underlying concepts align closely with regulatory expectations around governance, risk management and client outcomes. Many advisers, AFSLs and ACLs can improve resilience by adopting CPS 230-style practices, particularly around outsourcing, business continuity planning and testing critical controls.

Keep exploring

Subscribe

Every fortnight “Three Hit Tuesday” delivers thought leadership, considered analysis and insights that will help you improve your advice, more effectively manage your regulatory risks and make you better informed than your peers.

AS-Subscribe Form

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We respect your privacy. We know everyone says that, but we promise that we won’t sell your contact details to dodgy telemarketers, spam your email or otherwise exploit your trust.

Step 1 of 8 - Your Role

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Assess your ASIC exposure

Answer a few targeted questions to identify where your compliance may not stand up under ASIC review.

Takes less than 2 minutes. No preparation required.

What best describes your role?