Future Advice

Future Advice

“The future is no more uncertain than the present”

— Walt Whitman “Compliance and Financial Services (3rd Edition)”

Have you Subscribed?

Planning for the future

“The purpose of thinking about the future is not to predict it but to raise people’s hopes.”

— Freeman Dyson, Treasury?

A key consideration in the majority of financial advice complaints AFCA handle is evaluating whether clients have provided informed consent for the advice.

Informed consent is based on a client’s understanding of, and agreement with, the strategies and tactics advisers propose to satisfy their clients’ immediate and future needs. And, increasingly, advisers need to consider the broader implications, and future consequences, of the strategies and tactics they propose.

But the future is, as economists prove on a daily basis, both uncertain and unpredictable.

Given this reality, how much consideration of future events should be included in your Statements of Advice (SoA)?

By looking too far ahead, or “future-proofing” your advice, are you confusing your clients and adding unnecessary complexity?

As controversial as it may seem, perhaps being less ambitious is the key to producing clear, concise and effective advice.

In practical terms it’s a balancing act: producing SoAs requires time and resources and advisers and, for a variety of reasons, advisers are often tempted to cover as much ground as possible.

Typical questions we are asked include:

  • “How many years ahead can I recommend non-concessional contributions for?”
  • “Can I make recommendations now for the proceeds of a property sale next year”?
  • “Should I model to life expectancy?”

To answer such questions, it is necessary to consider:

  • What is the purpose and function of a Statement of Advice (SoA)? and 
  • What are the “sources of truth” for your strategic advice plan for a client?

 A Stitch in Time

“I saw the decade in, when it seemed the world could change at the blink of an eye”

— Senator Jane Hume, Former Minister for Superannuation, Financial Services and the Digital Economy (or perhaps Jesus Jones “Right here, right now”)

Most advisers understand that:

  • SoAs are required for recommendations about financial products, or classes of financial products (s766B).
  • They are documents designed “to help clients understand, and decide whether to rely on, retail financial advice” (RG 175.167).
  • An SoA needs to present information in a clear and concise manner (s947B(6) and s947C(6)).
  • SoAs are intended to “communicate to a clients specific information at a point in time” (RG 90.41).

I recently reviewed an SoA where the adviser provided a strategic recommendation that the clients purchase an investment property in their own names once their home loan was paid off… in about 5 years’ time:

  • It is hard to see how a recommendation for 5 years in the future is necessary to communicating particular product information at a point in time.
  • The clients’ relevant circumstances, and/or legislation, are very likely to have changed in 5 years’ time.

Quite apart from the fact that direct property is not generally classified as “financial product advice”, it would have been better to frame this as a future consideration instead of a recommendation or, better yet, omit this recommendation from the SoA entirely.

A more common and problematic dilemma is whether to provide specific future-dated product advice related to investing the proceeds of downsizing a home, or selling an investment property, for example in 2 years’ time. Unless the future strategy is integral to the basis for the advice about a financial product being provided at a given point in time, including it in an SoA is entirely optional, and may create more problems than it solves.

TIP: An SoA needs to contain the basis for your advice but does not need to be the “road map to life expectancy”.


 The Goldilocks Principle

“I want it all, I want it all, I want it all, and I want it now”

— Consumer Expectations Report 2021 (or Queen)

The Goldilocks Effect Principle — derived from the medieval crime parable involving three ursine victims and an entitled blonde housebreaker – is the idea that people are inclined to pursue not the ideal outcome, but an outcome that is ‘just right’.

In the context of advice services, advisers may operationalise this principle by offering three distinct service offers at different price points. In the context of advice, they may offer Wholistic advice, Scaled Advice or Limited Advice. Although all advice is scaled (and to a degree limited), wholistic advice is more ambitious and aspirational than scaled advice that generally focuses on appropriateness and immediacy. Limited advice generally lacks the strategic focus of either wholistic or scaled advice to offer transactional solutions.

In a principles-based regulatory regime, the question of what is “just right” is fundamental.

Remember that there are strict laws relating to financial product advice so, when deciding how much information about future events to put in an SoA, one needs to appreciate that:

  • Trying to incorporate a new client’s entire advice strategy in a single 100-page “foundation” SoA, including product advice and potential product switches, is likely to run afoul of the requirement for clear, concise and effective advice.
  • Conversely, providing narrowly scoped initial advice without discussing or addressing the clients larger concerns and relevant circumstances puts advisers at risk of breaching conflict laws (s961J) and also the Code of Ethics.
  • ASIC do not endorse advisers drafting SoAs that “include advice on broad topics… for the main purpose of using a Record of Advice rather than an SoA in future”. 
  • ASIC have made it clear that the key is not to answer all concerns in one master document, but instead to be clear with clients about when different aspects of their financial needs will be formally addressed.
  • AFCA “assess the conduct of a financial firm over the lifetime of the firm’s relationship with its customer”. Informed consent is necessary throughout the engagement.

TIP: Your SoAs should neither be too narrow, not too broad: remember the Goldilocks principle and aim for just right! 


The NCC Nexus

“If you could attenuate to every strand of quivering data, the future would be entirely calculable. As inevitable as mathematics.”

— Sherlock “The Six Thatchers”

 Advice about maximising non-concessional contributions (NCCs), or equalising superannuation balances or maximising Centrelink benefits, often requires a multi-year strategy – and hence provides an interesting nexus between product and strategy advice.

The following is a typical advice scenario in the lead-up to a client retiring:

In Sep 2022, a 58-year-old client has $700,000 cash to invest, and $100,000 in existing superannuation fund A (accumulation).

The recommendation was structured as a series of steps over four years as depicted in the accompanying table.

In this instance:

  • To satisfy product replacement considerations required under s947D(2), should cost comparisons in the Sep 2022 SoA be based on a balance of $100,000, $210,000, $530,000, or indeed $800,000?
  • Is it reasonable to make firm financial product recommendations for 2026 now, and can the costs or features of a superannuation product based on an expected balance in 2026 be used as part of the basis for the product replacement now?
  • Can a Record of Advice be used in 2026 for the pension refresh, assuming the clients’ circumstances in 2026 match up with the projected circumstances outlined in the SoA?

Without getting bogged down in para-planning wars, we would argue that it is difficult to make future-dated tactical recommendations with any real precision past 12 months, and it can be outright problematic past 3 years:

  • Your client may well follow the roadmap you envisage, but then again, for a variety of reasons, they might not.
  • Providing firm recommendations out to August 2023 would not be unreasonable.
  • However, whilst the likely features and benefits (e.g. cost) of a superannuation product based on an expected balance in four years’ time may have a bearing on your recommendations, in most cases it would be unwise to use this as the main basis for your advice now.
  • Relying on an RoA in 2026 to give advice about a pension refresh outlined in an SoA in 2022 may be taking on more regulatory risk than you need. Do you really want to prove why there has been no material or significant change for the client? Moreover, you should consider whether an RoA might be a more appropriate vehicle for demonstrating your client’s informed consent.

TIP: Only provide the product recommendations in an SoA that you actually need to. 


The source of (imperfect) truth 

“No human action is ever truly random. An advanced grasp of the mathematics of probability mapped onto a thorough apprehension of human psychology and the known dispositions of any given individual can reduce the number of variables considerably.”

— Introduction to Financial Planning I (or Sherlock “The Six Thatchers”)

One approach an increasing number of advisers are using is elegantly simple: utilise Strategy SoAs to capture the broader strategic advice recommendations related to classes of financial products, targeted SoAs for specific financial product advice when and as required, and a Strategy Summary page that encapsulates the “bigger picture” in a client-friendly format. Using such an approach, you may find that:

  • Your Strategy SoAs are dynamic and flexible, and don’t need to include cumbersome details about future-dated product advice.
  • The Strategy Summary can be easily updated at each review, held “front and centre” in the client file, and from a compliance perspective will assist with demonstrating you are meeting safe harbour steps and considering the clients’ relevant circumstances.
  • The SoAs you produce will be simpler and cheaper to produce than in the traditional “everything but the kitchen sink” approach.

Of course, the key to success with such an approach is to utilise “incorporation by reference” and keep at hand a clear summary of what advice documents have been provided, and when.

TIP: The source of truth for your advice don’t have to be one all-encompassing SoA. Good advice is both tactical and strategic in nature and involves constant re-testing and re-evaluation of its adequacy and appropriateness. 


The modelling mire

“All models are wrong, but some are useful”

— Aphorism (popularly credited to Tyra Banks)

Modelling, used judiciously, is a powerful and frequently necessary part of the advice process.

For example, ASIC indicated in RG90 that advisers should model the impact of insurance premiums funded via superannuation on a clients’ super balance over a relevant period and include the impact in the SoA.

That said, modelling is only a guide, and clarity sometimes means acknowledging the inability to be specific:

  • Using straight-line return assumptions for financial investments to quantify longevity risk in retirement denies the reality of sequencing risk, and hence can be inherently inaccurate.
  • Modelling insurance premiums (for example for a 55-year-old on stepped premiums) can be an art as much as a science.
  • Modelling that doesn’t consider key costs such as material adviser service fees and product costs could be misleading.

SoAs can (and sometimes must) refer to modelling that has been conducted to support the basis for the advice being provided. However, you have the option of including this by incorporation rather than within the SoA itself. Moreover, modelling should always come with appropriate caveats.

Tip: Modelling can be powerful and can form part of the basis of your advice. But if it is overly simplistic and gives rise to unjustified confidence (or overly complex and hard to understand) it may not belong in the SoA.


Putting it in Practice

“You can never predict how markets will react. You can model it. You may try to predict it, but weather and markets and risk, only God knows.”

— Rakesh Jhunjhunwala, Billionaire business magnate, stock trader, and investor

The practical challenge advisers often face is reconciling their clients’ current needs and circumstances against anticipated events and future circumstances.

It’s an obligation made more difficult by a regulatory hesitation to allow advisers to embrace historic factors and Treasury’s imposition of an obligation to see further and more broadly.

The further an adviser looks, the greater their capacity to identify (and anticipate) future needs, consequences and impacts. Except, the future is unpredictable and being too ambitious often produces sub-optimal outcomes: assumptions that are unreasonable, conclusions that are improbable or, at best, lengthy, ambiguous and highly qualified advice documents that sabotage any possibility of obtaining the client’s free, informed and prior consent.

For better or worse, it is up to each adviser to determine the right balance – the Goldilocks solution that leads to advice that is ‘just right’ in balancing immediate needs and future considerations. Remember, the law is principles-based and each provider can take its own approach to providing clear, concise and effective advice.

As equivocal as this is, it actually gives you a lot of freedom to provide shorter, simpler and more effective SoAs. If you’d like our help to do so, please reach out.

Have you subscribed?

Keep exploring

Subscribe

Every fortnight “Three Hit Tuesday” delivers thought leadership, considered analysis and insights that will help you improve your advice, more effectively manage your regulatory risks and make you better informed than your peers.

AS-Subscribe Form

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We respect your privacy. We know everyone says that, but we promise that we won’t sell your contact details to dodgy telemarketers, spam your email or otherwise exploit your trust.

Step 1 of 8 - Your Role

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Assess your ASIC exposure

Answer a few targeted questions to identify where your compliance may not stand up under ASIC review.

Takes less than 2 minutes. No preparation required.

What best describes your role?