Head to Head: Best interests, mortgages and financial product advice.

Head to Head: Best interests, mortgages and financial product advice.

“These brokers keep yapping about Best Interest Duty as if it is as simple as acting in the best interests of a customer. Imagine if they knew what was involved to actually meet those requirements to a ASIC standard.”

— PROPERTY GURU BACKS BEST INTERESTS DUTY FOR MORTGAGE BROKERS, ifa, 25 February 2019

SUBSCRIBE

1. “Mortgage brokers only care about commissions. Financial planners, like other professionals, have fiduciary obligations”.

SEAN: Financial planners have fiduciary-like obligations, but they’re not traditional fiduciaries despite “the entrustment of one to another and the position of vulnerability it creates”[i]. If they were fiduciaries, they’d be no need for the conflict priority rule, prohibitions on conflicted remuneration or a statutory duty to act in their clients’ interests. But whether they’re fiduciaries, or whether the law will stretch to include them as a new class of fiduciary, is irrelevant.

Financial planning emerged from product distribution and, let’s not forget, is regulated as financial product advice.

Recognising the past doesn’t constrain the future or prevent the emergence of an advice profession, but an advice profession doesn’t need to be built on the bones of mortgage brokers. If financial planners can move beyond conflicted remuneration, volume bonuses and product sales, then credit representatives can do the same. In fact, some might say they’re better placed to do so.

For advisers, intent is as critical as process and outcomes. Mortgage brokers also have an obligation to act in their best interests but, interestingly enough, approach their duty without the (dubious) security provided by the ‘safe harbour’ steps. Personally, I think that’s to their significant advantage, but they will have to take additional steps to ensure their duty to their client and their clients’ interests don’t conflict with their private interests. Like other advice professionals, how they model independence and impartiality will be challenging given their remuneration model and association, but no more impossible for them than it is for financial planners.

ANGELIQUE: Pot calling kettle. I think the introduction of the future of financial advice (FOFA) reforms, was to a large extent, all about commissions in the financial advice space.

The mortgage broker plays an incredibly important role in a persons life. For the average, and majority of people they facilitate the purchase of the largest single asset an individual acquires in their life. You will generally never borrow the amount of money you do when purchasing a house. Taking out a home loan is one of the biggest financial decisions you will make. https://download.asic.gov.au/media/5249601/rep628-published-29-august-2019.pdf

The mortgage broker makes your dreams come true and for a majority of brokers, they do an outstanding job.

The lending space, and the laws are so much newer and, in my opinion, devoid of the gremlins that the financial advice laws suffer. It seems that with the birth of the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009,  and the most recent introduction of best interest duty obligations for the mortgage broker, ASIC has been given the flexibility to draft better laws in the Credit Protection space.

The introduction of the best interest obligations for mortgage brokers, has introduced fiduciary-like obligations. In drafting BID for brokers, ASIC had the opportunity to lose the pesky safe-harbour gremlin. ASIC has rightly, and overtly not introduced this process step when drafting BID for the mortgage broker regime. Instead, obligations for mortgage-brokers are high-level principles, and do not contain prescriptive steps for mortgage brokers to follow. For those of you who have been around long enough, BID for the financial planning industry in its earliest drafting did not contain a safe harbour. As time progressed and the large institutions trudged up the hill to the ACT and lobbied, we saw the birth of safe harbour and a process the major institutions could rely on for their financial planning factories.

Refreshingly for the mortgage broker, what conduct satisfies this duty will depend on the individual circumstances in which credit assistance is provided to the consumer. It is the responsibility of mortgage brokers to ensure that their conduct meets the standards of BID in the relevant circumstances.   Brokers will need to use their judgement when determining what is in the customers’ best interests. And this might include challenging the consumers’ perception of their best interests. Of course, in addition, the broker will also need to meet the responsible lending obligations.


2. “Financial planning businesses have obligations Brokers simply can’t satisfy”

ANGELIQUE: Like the advice profession, mortgage brokers will also need to prioritise clients’ interests’ and will need a compliance framework which incorporates an end-to-end approach, including training, tools and templates and an audit process. This is particularly important as ASIC in their latest Corporate Plan, will be launching a surveillance project targeting mortgage broker accountability.

It is a shame the advice profession has been pushed into a process that sometimes seem counter- productive to the best interests of the client.

BID for the mortgage broker has been drafted as a principle based standard and more eloquently accommodates a brokers’ role in ensuring they are able to do what is best for their client. Sometimes the client themselves may be acting in a manner that is not in their best interest, and as a mortgage broker/adviser it falls to you, and your duty, to sometimes have a hard conversation. You may be dealing with a client who has unrealistic expectations, they have very little super or savings and want to retire maintaining a certain life-style;  or suffering from FOMO (fear of missing out) because their neighbours are driving the latest tesla.

The Safe Harbour provisions and the process sometimes misses this very point as it forces you through a strict list, which some would argue is counter intuitive to assisting you in your duty to engage in what is best for your client.

SEAN: I don’t agree with either premise. First, all advice is scaled. The contention that on the basis of limited interaction, cursory discovery and a biased assessment of my needs and circumstances, someone can provide advice that addresses all my needs and circumstances is preposterous. At best, professional advisers can provide considered, tailored and effective advice on some key elements, but not everything and certainly not at once.

If we step away from the confines of Chapter 7 for a moment, advice is nothing more than a considered opinion based on context, circumstances and the bona fide assessment of alternatives.

Financial Planners had a clear lead over mortgage brokers, but they should recall the fable of the tortoise and the hare; the gap is dwindling and unless they start making inroads, they may soon be overtaken.  

3. “Financial planning is about wholistic advice. Mortgage broking isn’t even advice.”

SEAN: I don’t agree with either premise. First, all advice is scaled. The contention that on the basis of limited interaction, cursory discovery and a biased assessment of my needs and circumstances, someone can provide advice that addresses all my needs and circumstances is preposterous. At best, professional advisers can provide considered, tailored and effective advice on some key elements, but not everything and certainly not at once.

If we step away from the confines of Chapter 7 for a moment, advice is nothing more than a considered opinion based on context, circumstances and the bona fide assessment of alternatives.

Financial Planners had a clear lead over mortgage brokers, but they should recall the fable of the tortoise and the hare; the gap is dwindling and unless they start making inroads, they may soon be overtaken.  

ANGELIQUE: Mortgage broking is clear in terms of what it is and what it is not. It is about assisting consumers with their lending needs. And the discovery process the broker needs to undertake, has all the hall marks of the financial advice compliance obligations.  Just like the adviser, the mortgage broker must:

  • be licenced;
  • provide financial services efficiently, honestly and fairly;
  • ensure that clients are not disadvantaged by any conflict of interest;
  • comply with the Act, the Code and licence conditions; and
  • have in place internal dispute resolution procedures and be a member of an approved external dispute resolution scheme.

In addition, they must comply with responsible lending rules, and in accordance with Chapter 3 of the Act, they can not enter into contracts with consumers that would find it difficult to make their repayments.

Credit suitability is another important aspect of a mortgage brokers obligations and they are required to:

  • Make reasonable enquiries about the consumers’ financial situation, their requirements and objectives (sound familiar Sean?);
  • Take reasonable steps to verify the consumers’ financial situation; and
  • Based on these enquiries, assess whether the credit contract is ‘not unsuitable’ for the consumer, the consumer’s ability to repay the loan without ‘substantial hardship’.

4. “Financial planning is about relationships. Broking is transactional.”

ANGELIQUE: Myth busted, in an ASIC investigation they found that 60% of consumers took out a home loan with a lender they had an existing relationship with. Consumers who went direct to a lender were more likely to take out their loan with a lender they had an existing relationship with (69%) than consumers who took out their loan through a broker (49%). https://download.asic.gov.au/media/5249601/rep628-published-29-august-2019.pdf

In a research paper prepared by ASIC, it seems that brokers tend to be operating on the more transactional side than lenders, with 53% of first home buyers taking out their loan via a broker as compared to a lender, in comparison to non-first home buyers who tended to borrow via their lender.

I will concede the point that broking is transactional, however, just like the adviser, the broker must establish a trusting relationship in order to determine suitability and comply with responsible lending obligations. I would suggest, the better financial advisers, are doing what the broker needs to when determining suitability. They have the hard conversations to determine income and expenses, and establish realistic goals based on income and budget.

SEAN: I appreciate that consumers tend to re-engage their brokers for subsequent transactions, but that’s probably convenience more than a relationship. I barely remember the broker that initially advised me, but I’ve referred others to him and have emailed him once in the last eight years (I’m still waiting on a response).

A “relationship” requires trust, reliance and mutual commitments. A second or third transaction is no more evidence of a ‘relationship’ than is an Authority to Proceed or an Ongoing Service Agreement. One of the great leap forwards that the financial planning industry has made is to move beyond formalism and focus on engagement, understanding and ethical duties. This mindshift has laid the foundation for an emerging advice profession but mortgage brokers are emulating that shift; as evidenced by the increasing number of brokers recognising that their BID often requires them to refer their clients to insurance advisers.

Keep exploring

Subscribe

Every fortnight “Three Hit Tuesday” delivers thought leadership, considered analysis and insights that will help you improve your advice, more effectively manage your regulatory risks and make you better informed than your peers.

AS-Subscribe Form

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We respect your privacy. We know everyone says that, but we promise that we won’t sell your contact details to dodgy telemarketers, spam your email or otherwise exploit your trust.

Step 1 of 8 - Your Role

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Assess your ASIC exposure

Answer a few targeted questions to identify where your compliance may not stand up under ASIC review.

Takes less than 2 minutes. No preparation required.

What best describes your role?