In my defense, I have none.
Taylor Swift on her MDA services
Many advice practices now offer Managed Discretionary Account (MDA) services, yet the governance, documentation and oversight required are often underestimated. ASIC’s Regulatory Guide 179 Managed discretionary accounts (issued September 2016) sets out ASIC’s expectations for MDA services provided to retail clients.
In practice, most MDA documentation is legally sound, but investment governance often lacks clarity, consistency and defensible processes. These gaps create avoidable audit risks and reduce transparency around how discretionary decisions are made.
A well-designed Investment Policy Statement (IPS) closes these gaps by creating an agreed framework for investment objectives, risk limits, asset allocation, benchmarking, rebalancing and governance. Beyond meeting regulatory expectations, a strategically designed Investment Policy Statement (IPS) positions the MDA as a forward-looking, belief-driven investment capability rather than a compliance-led structure. It emphasises long-term value creation, adaptability and stewardship.
What is an Investment Policy Statement (and how does it differ from an Investment Program)?
An IPS is first and foremost a strategic framework for the investment committee or AFSL. It clarifies the investment philosophy, long-term objectives, and guiding principles that shape the portfolio, while also documenting the rules, structure, and processes that support discretionary investment decisions. It documents the rules, structure and processes that guide the discretionary investment service. In contrast, an Investment Program is the client-specific, ASIC-prescribed document that applies the IPS framework to an individual retail client.
IPS (committee level)
- Investment philosophy and decision‑making principles
- Strategic asset allocation (SAA), ranges and constraints
- Benchmark selection and rebalancing triggers
- Governance, review cycles and documentation standards
Investment Program (client level)
- Client objectives, needs and constraints
- Risk tolerance and suitability assessment
- Application of the IPS to the client’s circumstances
- Required disclosures and warnings
Ben McMahon’s article, “The Importance of an Investment Policy Statement in Managing MDAs”, highlights that many advice practices adopt MDAs without the governance, structure, and clarity required for defensible discretionary management. He explains that a well-designed IPS provides the essential framework for investment philosophy, risk limits, SAA, benchmarking, and oversight, enabling consistent decision-making, meaningful performance attribution, stronger compliance, and clearer client communication.
How does an IPS support a licensee’s compliance and risk management framework?
A cohesive IPS treats risk as both a structural and an adaptive function. Traditional parameters, such as SAA ranges, liquidity thresholds and rebalancing triggers, remain essential for transparency and defensibility. However, committees increasingly need to recognise that risk is also dynamic and system‑driven, shaped by market regimes, behavioural tendencies and interconnected forces.
A strategic IPS therefore integrates both perspectives: defining clear, testable limits while acknowledging that risk evolves through liquidity stresses, regime shifts, concentration exposure and behavioural patterns. Positioning risk this way helps AFSLs evidence the general obligations in s912A, RG104 and RG 179 without reducing risk management to static control settings alone.
Clear governance parameters support auditability and accountability, while adaptive risk thinking ensures committees remain responsive, forward‑looking, and adaptable to emerging conditions. A formal IPS also helps AFSLs evidence their compliance with s912A by showing how discretion is controlled, documented and reviewed. It also directly aligns with RG 179 obligations on suitability, ongoing reviews, and the annual audit of internal control procedures for MDA providers.
Clear parameters mean decisions are auditable, repeatable and less exposed to personal bias or market noise. This protects Responsible Managers, advisers and the AFSL during ASIC surveillance, file reviews and MDA audits.
Seven practical ways an IPS strengthens your MDA
1. Aligns purpose, objectives and client-centred design
An IPS forces clarity on what the portfolio is designed to achieve and how each component contributes to outcomes. This supports consistent, evidence‑based advice.
2. Enables meaningful performance attribution
With SAA and benchmarks defined in the IPS, attribution can be clearly separated between:
- Asset allocation (did the weighting help?)
- Security or manager selection (did the choice add value?)
For example, a portfolio may show: domestic equities +1.2% above benchmark; international equities -0.8% below benchmark. Such insights help committees focus on where they add value.
3. Articulates investment philosophy
Documenting the committee’s beliefs within the IPS ensures decisions remain anchored in agreed principles during volatility, and helps the IPS provide a consistent philosophical foundation for all investment activities.
4. Sets mandate boundaries and constraints
The IPS should clearly set out which asset classes may be used, how managers are selected, and the rules for liquidity and rebalancing, so that clients are protected and portfolios are implemented consistently.
5. Strengthens governance and accountability
An IPS creates transparency over who decides, when they decide and how decisions must be recorded, ensuring governance expectations are unambiguous and consistently applied.
6. Lifts professionalism beyond MDAs
The IPS provides a structured governance model that enhances SMAs, model portfolios and advice committees by embedding clear processes, disciplined oversight and documented decision‑making frameworks.
7. Simplifies creation of ASIC-compliant Investment Programs
With the IPS doing the heavy lifting, Investment Programs become clearer, more consistent and less prone to ad hoc risk.
How can an IPS improve performance communication with clients?
A consistent governance framework makes reporting clearer and more compelling. Committees can link decisions to outcomes and explain whether value came from allocation, selection or disciplined rebalancing.
This strengthens trust and supports constructive client conversations.
What are the operational challenges in maintaining a “live” IPS?
Keeping the IPS up to date is one of the most significant challenges for any MDA operator. Without disciplined review cycles, version control, and governance oversight, an IPS can quickly fall out of step with market conditions, committee decisions, or an evolving investment philosophy.
Operationally, Committees should nominate custodians to maintain the document, record all changes in formal minutes, and ensure that independent compliance reviews validate that the practice aligns with policy.
How can an IPS avoid a compliance-only mindset?
While the IPS supports AFSL and RG 179 obligations, its primary purpose is strategic rather than defensive. An effective IPS embeds long‑term stewardship, genuine investment beliefs and a forward‑looking view of client value.
This helps committees avoid treating the IPS as a regulatory shield and instead use it as a compass for innovation, disciplined risk‑taking and adaptive decision‑making.
How can committees infuse the IPS with philosophical depth?
It is important to acknowledge that an IPS document can only offer a starting point. An IPS cannot fully resolve deeper questions of stewardship, ethical responsibility, intergenerational value, or the moral foundations of investment decision‑making. These require ongoing dialogue, cultural maturity and reflective practice that extends beyond formal documentation.
A strong IPS articulates investment beliefs with clarity: how markets work, where value is created, how risk is priced and why the committee expects certain strategies to succeed over long horizons. Documenting these beliefs strengthens resilience during volatility and prevents reactive, short‑term behaviour. Committees should revisit their beliefs annually and test whether they remain coherent in light of evolving evidence.
What if the investment committee isn’t mature enough for an IPS?
Many IPS discussions implicitly assume a level of governance sophistication that not all committees possess. It’s important to recognise that committee maturity varies widely, and an IPS cannot compensate for weak culture, unclear authority or inconsistent behaviour without deliberate capability‑building.
Not all committees begin with, or even develop, strong governance capability. The IPS can help build maturity by defining roles, decision rights, escalation paths and behavioural expectations. Training, structured facilitation and periodic independent reviews accelerate decision‑making discipline and ensure committee dynamics support, not undermine, strategy.
Should risk be understood in a static or adaptive systems-aware way?
Risk should be understood as both structural and adaptive. A purely static view, focused on volatility, benchmarks and predefined ranges, captures only part of the picture. An adaptive, systems‑aware interpretation expands this understanding by considering liquidity pressures, market‑regime shifts, behavioural traps, concentration risks and the feedback loops present in interconnected markets. This approach treats risk as something to be monitored, questioned and recalibrated as conditions evolve.
By integrating adaptive awareness with traditional parameter‑based controls, the IPS offers a unified risk framework. Clear limits remain important, but they sit alongside a deliberate commitment to reassessment, environmental scanning and responsive adjustment, ensuring risk management evolves with the system it operates within.
How does the IPS balance attribution with long-term value creation?
Performance attribution helps explain what happened, but long‑term success depends on consistent process, horizon discipline and strategic clarity. A mature IPS emphasises long‑term value creation, stewardship and resilience, ensuring committees avoid overreacting to quarterly performance noise. Attribution should serve understanding, not dictate short‑term decisions.
What now?
If you’re operating, or planning, an MDA service, your IPS is no longer a “nice to have” – it’s the evidence your discretion is controlled, explainable and compliant. Assured Support, with our friends at MDA Guru, can help you design, test and review IPS frameworks that satisfy ASIC, support AFSL governance and give your committee real insight into risk and performance. Talk to us before your next audit, not after it.
If you enjoyed this, we recommend that you read:
- The Importance of an Investment Policy Statement in Managing MDAs
- Clarifying the MDA Audit: What AFSLs with MDA Authorisations Need to Know
- SMA or MDA? That is the question
- MDA Boutique vs SMA High Street
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What’s the difference between an IPS and an Investment Program?
An IPS sets the AFSL/committee-level framework—philosophy, SAA ranges, benchmarks, rebalancing and governance. An Investment Program applies that framework to a particular retail client, addressing objectives, constraints and suitability disclosures required under ASIC’s MDA policy.
2. How does an IPS help us meet AFSL obligations?
By codifying processes, limits, documentation and reviews, an IPS evidences compliance with s912A (efficiently, honestly and fairly; adequate resources; competence; training; risk systems; dispute resolution) and supports RG 104 expectations for systems and controls.
3. What does RG 179 expect for MDAs?
RG 179 outlines how ASIC regulates MDAs for retail clients, covering suitability, ongoing reviews and internal control procedures that must be audited annually after year-end.
4. How does an IPS improve performance conversations?
Clear SAA, ranges, and benchmarks enable attribution between allocation and selection, making reports explainable and tying committee decisions to outcomes that clients can understand.
5. What keeps an IPS “live” and defensible?
Set review cycles, version control, role custodians and independent compliance checks. Record changes in minutes and audit control procedures annually in line with RG 179.