Choosing a Licensee: The Crucial Question Advisers Forget to Ask
I remember it all too well
Taylor Swift
Steve had built his practice over fifteen years. Good clients, strong relationships, a reputation for putting people first and a history of good compliance audits. Then he put in his notice to join another Licensee. Suddenly, another audit was requested and, even more suddenly, major (but unarticulated) compliance issues were identified. The Licensee retained all of Steve’s revenue and insisted on remediation, without identifying any specific issues and while delaying action and refusing to confirm its concerns in writing. The Licensee ignored Steve (and his representative), ignored s912A and relied on “legal advice” that couldn’t have been provided by a competent legal professional. The result: Steve’s business (and the continued employment of his staff) was compromised by a Licensee determined to retain his remuneration. The Licensee didn’t even pretend to act reasonably but simply gambled that Steve couldn’t (and wouldn’t) take them on.
It’s easy to focus on the upsides when switching licensees: better support, stronger compliance, and a team that understands your practice. Ask around, and you’ll hear a few good names. Some licensees are excellent—they know their obligations, respect advisers, and add real value without compromising professionalism.
But here’s the question too few advisers ask:
Which licensees should I avoid?
It’s a far better question. Because the damage a bad licensee can cause is much harder to repair than the benefits a good one can deliver. And they’re out there—some dressed in polish and prestige, others in chaos masquerading as flexibility.
The Red Flags You Can’t Ignore
Problematic licensees tend to have certain traits in common:
They distort the law to suit their interests. Vague references to “industry practices” or “ASIC’s expectations” often conceal ignorance, incompetence or indifference. When a licensee can’t clearly explain their position or avoids putting it in writing, you’re not dealing with professionals—you’re dealing with a risk. The so-called “leaders” who depend on self-promotion often disappear when the regulator arrives.
Their compliance framework is a time capsule—or a concept of a plan. Ask to see their compliance documentation. If their best documentation is a PDF from 2019 or a poorly branded off-the-shelf policy suite, it’s not just lazy—it’s dangerous. Regulators and courts (see Financial Circle) assess substance over form. A polished template is no substitute for active oversight and functional governance.
Leadership is disengaged. Leadership sets the tone, and when it’s apathetic or self-serving, the damage is systemic. We’ve seen licensees where the entire compliance team was a part-time admin assistant. We’ve seen others where executives (without legal or compliance expertise) dismissed concerns based on their own misinterpretation of the law. If compliance is viewed as a cost, it won’t be treated as a commitment. You can’t build a culture of integrity on a foundation of indifference, so investigate (and interrogate) the Leadership Team: find out what they’re known for and whether they have the skills and experience they claim.
They treat agreements and obligations like election promises—easily made and quickly forgotten. Licensees that alter fee structures without notice, reinterpret agreements mid-year, or renege on promised support will not stand with you when the pressure mounts.
They prioritise profit before ethics. When revenue is the Licensee’s dominant or sole concern, your reputation and livelihood become expendable. We’ve encountered licensees who “persuaded” employed advisers to recommend in-house products, despite obvious conflicts and undisclosed remuneration streams. These aren’t just ethical lapses—they are significant liabilities waiting to emerge.
They’re not lean businesses—they’re cadaverous. Under-resourced and overcommitted, some low-cost licensees cut deep corners and often can’t afford to provide the support you need (or employ the people with the skills to provide it). A lean business can be agile; a hollow one is brittle.
The Licensee is trapped in amber. No one likes change, but if your licensee isn’t actively helping you evolve through training, strategic support, or guidance, then you’re not a partner—you’re passive income.
Ignoring these issues isn’t about being risk-tolerant—it’s about being risk-blind. When you sign on with a bad licensee, you inherit more than their documents. You take on their culture, exposure, and the reputational damage they attract.
It’s not compliance risk. It’s business suicide.
At Assured Support, we work with advisers and licensees to build resilient, risk-aware practices. Our team specialises in Compliance Framework Development, Regulatory Support, and Independent Reviews that strengthen your standing and protect your livelihood.
The High Cost of the Wrong Choice
Bad licensees don’t just damage your compliance record. They extract a long-term toll and erode the wellbeing of the professionals, like you, who rely on them. When compliance frameworks are inadequate, support is absent, and leadership is indifferent, advisers absorb the fallout. They face increased stress, reputational damage, and, more often than not, the blame when things go wrong. The licensee may plead ignorance, settle quietly with ASIC, or scapegoat a “rogue adviser.” You’ll be left to manage the consequences: enforcement action, loss of clients, PI insurance issues, and lasting reputational harm.
This is not hypothetical. These are real-world risks. An adviser once rejected our advice to investigate, remediate and report “compliance issues” in his business on the basis that his licensee told him that no action was necessary; the significant legal and regulatory action that followed (along with the very public exposure) demonstrates why relying on a bad licensee’s advice is often a costly mistake.
Even without ill intent or obvious failures, poor compliance frameworks and weak licensee support directly worsen adviser mental health. The Australian Financial Advisers Wellbeing Report 2021, sponsored by AIA Australia and conducted by Dr Adam Fraser and Deakin University, found:
82% of advisers felt regulatory demands caused high or extreme stress
73% reported burnout
67% experienced symptoms of depression
One in three were receiving medical care due to compliance-related stress
Insurance News also noted that adviser wellbeing scores were among the lowest across all industries, with compliance burdens cited as the leading stressor.
The Real Costs Of Staying
Beyond regulatory risk, toxic licensees extract long-term costs that are harder to measure but no less severe:
Client trust: Your clients don’t see the licensee’s failings. They see missed deadlines and broken promises—and they blame you. Research and industry commentary support this concern. According to ASIC and adviser media such as RiskInfo and Professional Planner, when compliance breakdowns occur, it’s usually the adviser (not the licensee) who bears the brunt of client dissatisfaction and reputational harm.
Lost opportunity: Poor support and excessive admin bury your ability to grow, innovate, or deliver value. While direct Australian metrics are scarce, the sharp decline in adviser numbers, from approximately 28,000 in 2018 to around 11,000 by 2024, is widely attributed to high regulatory, insurance, and compensation costs. Time and energy diverted to compliance under underperforming licensees hampers advisers’ capacity for growth and client focus.
Professional stagnation: Bad licensees don’t invest in adviser training. You’re left behind while others surge ahead. According to ASIC’s Regulatory Guide 146, licensees must ensure their representatives meet minimum training standards and maintain ongoing professional development. ASIC’s CPD standards require 40 hours of continuing education annually, much of which must be provided or approved by the licensee. Failing to meet these CPD requirements or to provide adequate support may result in enforcement outcomes. The Financial Services and Credit Panel (FSCP) has addressed several cases where advisers failed to meet CPD obligations, leading to sanctions, public warnings, or enforceable undertakings.
Mental fatigue: Stress compounds. So does silence. Too many advisers spend their careers tiptoeing around systemic dysfunction.
The Costs and Challenges of Moving-On
Let’s address the elephant in the room: switching licensees is disruptive. Here’s the real cost:
Financial impact:
Exit Costs: $5,000–$50,000
Legal Advice: $5,000–$10,000
Client communication: $2,000–$5,000
Lost productivity: 2–4 weeks
Potential restraint period: 0–12 months
When staying costs more than leaving:
Your licensee is under ASIC investigation
Compliance support is non-existent
Your reputation is being damaged by association
You’re spending more time on defensive documentation than client service
Your mental health is suffering
Minimising disruption:
Start documenting everything now
Build relationships with alternative licensees before you need them
Understand your contractual obligations
Prepare client communication templates in advance
Consider staged transitions for large practices
Legal Realities, Rights and Restrictions
Restraint clauses: Most are unenforceable if unreasonable, but fighting them costs money. Get legal advice early.
Client ownership: Generally yours if you brought them in, but check your agreement. Document your client relationships meticulously.
Notice periods: Usually 30–90 days. Use this time to prepare thoroughly, not to burn bridges.
IP and systems: Ensure you can extract your data and documents. Some licensees make this deliberately difficult.
Self-Licensing Isn’t for Everyone, But…
Self-licensing isn’t a silver bullet. It demands governance infrastructure, frameworks, technology, compliance expertise and real commitment to ongoing compliance.
But staying with a bad licensee is worse.
The real conversation isn’t “licensee or self-licensed?” It’s “good licensee or self-licensed?” Because staying with a poor licensee isn’t a strategy. It’s a slow professional death.
Don’t go it alone. Assured Support offers confidential, independent advice on licensee suitability and can help you benchmark your current arrangement against industry standards.
From Awareness to Action
Immediate steps (this week):
Score your current licensee against the prospective Licensee using our 50-point health check
Document any compliance concerns or support failures
Make a stay/go decision based on evidence, not hope
If staying, document your due diligence
If going, execute your transition plan methodically
Either way, never stop evaluating
Moving Past the Sales Pitch
If you’re considering a new licensee or reassessing your current one, go deeper than the marketing deck:
Talk to current and former advisers. Not just references. Find out who left and why.
Check ASIC’s enforcement record. Patterns matter more than one-offs.
Understand their finances. A licensee under stress cuts compliance corners.
Test their responsiveness. If they’re slow during the sales process, imagine how slow they’ll be once you’ve signed.
Check their systems. Paper-based processes in 2025 are not just outdated—they’re negligent.
Make Smarter Choices
Avoiding the wrong licensee is as important as choosing the right one. Here’s how to protect yourself:
Document everything. Every interaction, promise, and response.
Build your own knowledge. Don’t outsource your compliance literacy.
Network. Share war stories. Learn from others.
Have an exit strategy. Always know your plan B.
Review regularly. Check in yearly. Don’t let complacency dictate your future.
A Final Thought
Your licensee relationship isn’t just a business arrangement. It shapes your daily work, your professional growth, and your exposure to risk.
Too many advisers treat this choice as secondary, obsessing over revenue splits while ignoring culture and conduct. Don’t ignore ethical cancer because you’re distracted by a better remuneration model.
Choose licensees who view compliance as a competitive advantage, not a costly burden. Who invest in adviser success, not just extract adviser revenue. Who stand with their people under pressure, not sacrifice them for headlines.
We’re not here to name and shame. But if you want to protect your practice and your future, make smarter choices. Choose licensees with the culture, capability and competence to provide you with the support you need. Look for those licensees who invest in adviser success and who stay when things go wrong.
Australian Financial Services Compliance isn’t a checkbox. It’s your reputation, your clients, and your career.
Choose accordingly.
Smarter compliance starts with better conversations—and sometimes, those conversations need to be about walking away.
Book a confidential benchmark review with Assured Support today. Your licensee may be costing you more than you think.
1. What are the signs of a bad financial services licensee?
Common red flags include unclear compliance positions, disengaged leadership, outdated documentation, and profit-driven decisions at the expense of ethics and support.
2. How can a poor licensee relationship affect my business?
A toxic licensee can damage your reputation, limit your professional growth, increase regulatory risk, and compromise client trust—often leaving you to manage the fallout.
3. Is it worth the cost and effort to switch licensees?
While switching can be disruptive and expensive, the long-term cost of staying with a harmful licensee—mentally, professionally, and financially—is often greater.
4. What steps should I take before leaving my licensee?
Document everything, review your agreement, assess potential restraints, prepare client communications, and seek legal and compliance advice to plan a smooth transition.
5. Should I consider self-licensing as an alternative to a toxic AFSL?
Self-licensing offers control and autonomy, but it requires a significant investment in governance, compliance, and systems. It’s a viable option only for those willing to commit fully.
Fortnum Private Wealth’s $1.35 million penalty is a costly reminder that cybersecurity policies and compliance frameworks mean little without effective implementation and oversight. For AFS Licensees, the real test is whether risks are identified, deficiencies are addressed and governance arrangements produce evidence of meaningful action.
ASIC’s latest warning on lead generators exposes serious gaps in how AFS Licensees oversee referral arrangements, manage commercial conflicts and supervise their representatives. We examine the findings of Report 845 and what Licensees should do to ensure they understand, control and can demonstrate effective oversight of how their advice businesses acquire clients.
What happens when experienced Responsible Managers are put in charge of a fictional licensee riddled with compliance problems? Assured Support’s Before the Fall workshop revealed how politeness, misplaced confidence and unanswered questions can undermine effective oversight, and why knowing when to challenge reports matters just as much as knowing the rules.
Subscribe
Every fortnight “Three Hit Tuesday” delivers thought leadership, considered analysis and insights that will help you improve your advice, more effectively manage your regulatory risks and make you better informed than your peers.
AS-Subscribe Form
"*" indicates required fields
We respect your privacy. We know everyone says that, but we promise that we won’t sell your contact details to dodgy telemarketers, spam your email or otherwise exploit your trust.