Innovation’s All About Governance

Financial innovation is now a governance challenge. ASIC’s fintech and RegTech landscape review shows that AI, embedded finance, digital platforms and third-party technology providers are reshaping how financial services are delivered and supervised. For boards, directors, Responsible Managers and compliance leaders, the key issue isn’t whether new technologies are being adopted. It’s whether governance frameworks, accountability structures and oversight practices remain effective when technology becomes embedded in critical business decisions. Lessons from ASIC v Bekier and recent comments by Chief Justice Andrew Bell reinforce the same point: technology may assist decision-making, but it doesn’t replace informed judgement, active oversight or accountability.

Financial Innovation Is a Boardroom Issue

It’s difficult to keep pace with technological change. More than just challenging us to keep up, the rapid evolution of financial technology is reshaping how consumers and businesses access credit, insurance, payments, investment services and financial advice. Yet the most significant finding from the Digital Finance Cooperative Research Centre’s recent Innovation in Financial Technology and RegTech: A Landscape Review, prepared for the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), is that the next phase of innovation isn’t even primarily a technology story; it’s a governance story.

ASIC’s report examines innovation across seven jurisdictions, namely the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, the European Union, Switzerland, Hong Kong and Singapore, and concludes that advances in artificial intelligence (AI), data sharing, automation, cloud computing and digital platforms are reshaping how financial products are designed, distributed and supervised. Financial services are becoming increasingly digital, automated and integrated into broader platform ecosystems.

For regulators, licensees, Responsible Managers, directors and compliance professionals, the key challenge isn’t whether firms adopt innovative technologies. The challenge is ensuring that existing legal, conduct and governance obligations remain effective when those technologies are deployed at scale.

That challenge is increasingly being framed as a governance issue rather than a technology issue. Recent judicial and regulatory developments suggest that boards and senior executives are expected to understand, oversee and challenge emerging risks, even where those risks arise from complex operational systems, third-party providers or rapidly evolving technologies.

For example, the Federal Court’s decision in ASIC v Bekier reinforced the importance of active oversight and the need for directors and senior executives to engage meaningfully with material risks affecting their organisations. The decision reflects a broader regulatory expectation that accountability cannot be delegated simply because systems, processes or management structures exist.

In addition, recent commentary by NSW Chief Justice Andrew Bell highlighted a related concern; as artificial intelligence becomes more sophisticated and more deeply embedded within organisational decision-making, boards may face increasing risks if technology-generated outputs are accepted without sufficient scrutiny, challenge or independent judgement. The governance challenge isn’t merely to ensure that AI systems function effectively, but also to ensure decision-makers continue to exercise critical oversight when those systems influence significant decisions.

“As AI becomes more sophisticated and embedded within corporate activities, directors will need to make complex and situationally-specific decisions about their company’s creation and use of AI, with wide impacts on stakeholders“. – Vivienne Brand, ‘Directors’ Duties and AI Regulation’ (2025) 9 Law, Technology and Humans 1, 2

Importantly, recent regulatory and judicial developments suggest that technology governance is increasingly becoming a board-level responsibility. As financial services businesses become more dependent on algorithms, platforms and third-party providers, questions of accountability move beyond operational risk management and into the realm of governance, oversight and directors’ duties.

AI may be transforming financial services, but the real regulatory shift is in who remains accountable when automated systems make decisions. Governance, not technology, is becoming the defining risk.


The Rise of Embedded Finance

One of the report’s most significant observations is the continued growth of embedded finance. Financial products are increasingly being delivered through non-financial digital platforms rather than traditional financial institutions.

Small business lending provides a clear example. In the United States, platforms such as Shopify, Square (now Block), Amazon and PayPal are providing working capital finance directly within their ecosystems. Rather than completing a traditional loan application, merchants may receive pre-approved lending offers based on transaction data already held by the platform.

A similar trend is emerging in insurance. Travel insurance, device protection and other insurance products are increasingly offered during digital purchasing journeys. Consumers may purchase financial products while focused primarily on another transaction, raising important questions about informed decision-making and consumer understanding.

For regulators, the challenge is determining how accountability should be allocated when multiple parties contribute to a financial outcome. The lender, distributor, platform operator, technology provider and data provider may each perform part of the financial service chain. Traditional regulatory frameworks were largely designed around direct relationships between financial institutions and customers. Embedded finance increasingly blurs those boundaries.

For boards and senior management, this raises a related governance question: who within the organisation is responsible for understanding and overseeing risks that emerge across increasingly complex service chains? As distribution models become more fragmented, accountability frameworks must become more robust.


Artificial Intelligence Has Become Operational

The report also highlights the extent to which AI has moved beyond experimentation and into mainstream operational use.

AI systems are now routinely used in:

  • Credit underwriting and risk assessment;
  • Insurance pricing and claims processing;
  • Investment portfolio management;
  • Fraud detection and transaction monitoring; and
  • Regulatory compliance and reporting.

The insurance sector provides perhaps the clearest example of this shift. The report references United States-based insurer Lemonade, which has implemented AI throughout the insurance lifecycle. As at December 2024, approximately 55 per cent of claims were reportedly processed without human review, while 96 per cent of first notices of loss were handled through automated systems.

While these technologies offer efficiency gains and improved customer experiences, they also create new governance challenges. The report repeatedly identifies explainability, fairness, accountability and transparency as emerging supervisory priorities.

Regulators are increasingly focused on whether firms can explain automated decisions, identify potential bias and maintain meaningful human oversight. The question is no longer whether AI can improve operational outcomes. The question is whether firms can demonstrate that AI-driven decisions remain consistent with legal obligations and consumer protection expectations.

“Both board and algorithmic activities involve a degree of inscrutability – what happens in boards is not always transparent or easily reverse-engineered from subsequent events.” Vivienne Brand, ‘Directors’ Duties and AI Regulation’ (2025) 9 Law, Technology and Humans 1, 9

For Responsible Managers and compliance leaders, the governance challenge is often less about the algorithm itself and more about demonstrating evidence of oversight, challenge, review and accountability.


Technology Governance Is Now A Boardroom Issue

“Given AI’s complexity and inscrutability, effective oversight may be beyond the governance capabilities of many boards, even if supported by technology committees.” Vivienne Brand, ‘Directors’ Duties and AI Regulation’ (2025) 9 Law, Technology and Humans 1, 21

If effective oversight can’t be assumed, the practical question for Responsible Managers is whether governance arrangements can demonstrate who approved the decision, who challenged it, what evidence was considered and how the resulting risk was monitored.

The governance challenges identified in the DFCRC report are no longer merely theoretical regulatory concerns. They increasingly intersect with board oversight, executive accountability and organisational governance.

Recent judicial consideration of directors’ duties has reinforced the principle that boards cannot passively rely on management reporting, governance frameworks or technology systems when material risks emerge. Accountability remains with directors and senior executives, even where operational decisions are supported by sophisticated systems, external providers or automated processes.

This principle has important implications for financial institutions adopting AI-driven systems. Boards may need to understand not only the benefits of emerging technologies but also the governance frameworks that sit behind them. Questions about explainability, model validation, vendor oversight, escalation pathways and accountability structures are becoming increasingly important.

The practical challenge is that innovation often moves faster than governance. AI systems can evolve rapidly, embedded distribution models can blur responsibility, and third-party technology arrangements can create dependencies that are not always fully understood at the board level. At the same time, increasingly sophisticated AI systems may create a false sense of confidence in technology-generated outputs. Governance failures may arise not only from flawed models or poor data, but also from a diminished willingness to challenge assumptions, interrogate information or test conclusions.

As financial institutions become more technology-enabled, effective governance won’t depend on having policies in place, but on demonstrating active oversight, informed challenge and meaningful engagement with emerging risks. The central question for boards isn’t whether technology is being used. It’s whether governance arrangements ensure that accountability, judgment, and critical scrutiny remain effective when technology becomes embedded in decision-making processes.

For Responsible Managers, a useful governance test is whether the organisation can clearly identify who owns the decision, who challenges the decision, and what evidence demonstrates effective oversight.


A Shift Toward Outcomes-Based Regulation

“Despite flexibility and a contextual approach, directors’ duties remain black-letter law, distinguishable from softer codes of ethics and industry best practice guidelines. While still qualitative, purposive statements (and therefore ‘hard to game’), directors’ duties are much more than loose exhortations or vague good intentions”  Vivienne Brand, ‘Directors’ Duties and AI Regulation’ (2025) 9 Law, Technology and Humans 1, 10.

The report identifies a growing convergence in international regulatory approaches.

Although jurisdictions differ in their legislative frameworks, regulators are increasingly focused on customer outcomes rather than technology itself. The United Kingdom’s Consumer Duty, Australia’s Design and Distribution Obligations, and the European Union’s Consumer Credit Directive all reflect a broader emphasis on how consumers experience products rather than simply on how they are delivered.

This represents an important evolution in regulatory thinking.

Historically, financial regulation often focused on product categories, institutional boundaries and prescribed disclosure requirements. Modern digital ecosystems don’t neatly fit within those structures. Financial products may be delivered through technology platforms, mobile applications or integrated digital journeys that do not resemble traditional financial services distribution models.

As a result, regulators are increasingly asking a more fundamental question: Does the consumer understand that they are making a financial decision?

That question sits at the centre of emerging regulatory concerns regarding embedded credit, add-on insurance, digital investment prompts and other technology-enabled financial services.

Increasingly, regulators also appear to be asking a related governance question: can firms demonstrate who is accountable when those customer outcomes fall short of expectations?


What Boards and Responsible Managers Should Be Asking

  1. Can we explain how significant AI-driven decisions are made?
    Do we understand where AI influences customer, compliance, operational, or risk outcomes?
  2. Who is accountable for technology-driven customer outcomes?
    Are ownership, responsibilities, and decision-making authorities clearly defined?
  3. How do we evidence effective challenge, oversight, and governance?
    What reporting, testing, and review processes demonstrate active oversight?
  4. What third-party technology dependencies create material risk?
    Have key vendors, AI providers, and critical technology partners been appropriately assessed and monitored?
  5. Could we demonstrate effective AI governance to ASIC today?
    Can we readily produce evidence of accountability, risk management, oversight, and escalation processes?

Operational Resilience Is Becoming Strategic

Another important theme emerging from the report is operational resilience.

Financial institutions are increasingly dependent on cloud infrastructure, software providers, AI vendors and third-party technology partners. While these arrangements support innovation and efficiency, they also create concentration risk.

The report notes growing international concern that reliance on a relatively small number of technology providers may create systemic vulnerabilities. Regulatory initiatives such as the European Union’s Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA) and APRA’s Prudential Standard CPS 230 reflect increasing supervisory attention to these issues.

For boards and senior management, operational resilience is no longer simply an information technology concern. It is becoming a core governance issue.

Questions relating to outsourcing, vendor management, business continuity, cloud concentration and operational dependency are likely to become increasingly important components of regulatory oversight. More importantly, they are becoming matters that boards may need to understand, challenge and oversee with greater rigour than in the past.


Australia’s Position

The report concludes that Australia is comparatively well-positioned.

Recent reforms have brought Buy Now Pay Later providers within the National Consumer Credit Protection framework. Australia’s New Payments Platform and PayTo infrastructure are recognised as leading examples of real-time payments innovation. ASIC’s Report 798 and APRA’s CPS 230 demonstrate early regulatory engagement with AI governance and technology risk.

However, the report also identifies areas for further development.

These include:

  • More specific guidance regarding AI-driven decision-making.
  • Enhanced oversight of embedded financial products;
  • Expansion of open finance frameworks beyond banking data; and
  • Continued investment in regulatory technology and supervisory capability.

Importantly, the report does not advocate wholesale legislative reform. Instead, it suggests that Australia’s existing regulatory architecture provides a strong foundation. The challenge is ensuring that supervisory approaches evolve alongside increasingly complex digital business models.


Looking Ahead

Over the next five years, several developments appear particularly likely to shape the financial services landscape.

Embedded lending through digital platforms is expected to expand. AI-driven underwriting and claims processing are likely to become increasingly common. Account-to-account payment systems are expected to gain greater market share. Wealth management services are likely to become more personalised as broader financial data becomes available through open finance initiatives.

At the same time, significant uncertainties remain. The report notes that no major Buy Now Pay Later provider has yet to experience a genuine credit-cycle stress event. Questions surrounding liability for AI-generated decisions remain unresolved. More broadly, the governance implications of semi-autonomous financial systems continue to evolve.

For financial institutions, Responsible Managers, compliance leaders and directors, the message is becoming increasingly clear. The next phase of financial innovation will not be judged solely by technological capability. It will be judged by the quality of governance.

Regulators are focusing on accountability for automated decision-making, operational resilience, embedded distribution and AI governance. Courts are increasingly scrutinising how organisations identify, escalate and respond to emerging risks. Together, these developments signal a broader shift in regulatory expectations.

The lessons emerging from the DFCRC report, ASIC v Bekier and recent governance commentary from Chief Justice Andrew Bell point in the same direction. The central challenge is no longer whether organisations adopt AI and other advanced technologies. It is whether directors, executives and Responsible Managers continue to exercise informed judgement, meaningful oversight and effective challenge when those technologies become embedded in critical business processes.

Technology risk is no longer simply an operational issue. Technology risk is increasingly being treated as a governance, accountability and conduct issue, requiring active oversight from directors, Responsible Managers and senior executives.

Technology may be driving change, but governance will determine whether organisations, executives and boards remain trusted stewards of that change.

If you enjoyed this, we recommend that you read:

• What do Courts expect of Directors after ASIC v Bekier?

• The Hidden Risks of AI: ASIC’s Review of Licensees’ Embrace of Artificial Intelligence.

• Guide for Advisers and Licensees: AI and Financial Services

• Who’s Accountable for AFSL Compliance.

• What Good Compliance Infrastructure Looks Like.


Frequently Asked Questions

What does AI governance mean for Responsible Managers?

AI governance means ensuring automated systems remain subject to oversight, challenge and accountability. Responsible Managers should be able to explain who owns the process, how decisions are reviewed and what evidence demonstrates effective supervision.

Why are regulators focusing on governance rather than technology?

Because technology itself is not regulated. Regulators focus on outcomes, accountability and customer impacts. The key question is whether governance arrangements remain effective when technology is embedded in critical processes.

What risks arise from embedded finance?

Embedded finance can blur responsibility between lenders, distributors, platforms, technology providers and data providers. Firms need clear accountability frameworks to ensure customer outcomes remain appropriately governed.

How does CPS 230 relate to AI and technology risk?

CPS 230 reinforces expectations around operational resilience, service provider management and oversight of critical operations. These obligations become increasingly important as firms rely more heavily on technology and outsourcing arrangements.

What evidence should boards expect to see?

Boards should expect evidence of model governance, incident reporting, validation, vendor oversight, escalation pathways, challenge processes and accountability ownership. Policies alone are unlikely to demonstrate effective oversight.

Keep exploring

Subscribe

Every fortnight “Three Hit Tuesday” delivers thought leadership, considered analysis and insights that will help you improve your advice, more effectively manage your regulatory risks and make you better informed than your peers.

AS-Subscribe Form

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We respect your privacy. We know everyone says that, but we promise that we won’t sell your contact details to dodgy telemarketers, spam your email or otherwise exploit your trust.

Step 1 of 8 - Your Role

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Assess your ASIC exposure

Answer a few targeted questions to identify where your compliance may not stand up under ASIC review.

Takes less than 2 minutes. No preparation required.

What best describes your role?