“I’ve got a blank space, baby
And I’ll write your name.”Taylor Swift’s “Blank Space: Introduction to Financial Planning”
Let’s be frank: a checklist or process map isn’t transformative.
Despite your optimism, neither advice quality nor client outcomes will be improved by FDS changes or the introduction of qualified advisers. We can continue to play regulatory make-believe, but the reality is that we need a paradigm shift to move “financial advice” beyond disclosure, compliance, and product distribution.
We don’t need more regulation. We need more support to humanise and reframe our industrialised advice processes (and move from filling in blank spaces to understanding their content). Allow me to unpack more of my great advice beyond numbers.
For decades, associations, licensees and their compliance teams have emphasised fact-finding as the cornerstone of creating compliant advice and reasonable financial strategies. Financial advisers across Australia have been indoctrinated about the importance of gathering hard data: income figures, expense breakdowns, asset portfolios, and liability statements. So, competent advisers meticulously collect information about insurance policies, investment accounts, assets, liabilities and retirement plans.
This fact-centric approach has been the status quo and the foundation of a compliant advice profession.
That’s fair enough: this approach seems logical, comprehensive, and likely to deliver a reasonable outcome. After all, how can an adviser provide appropriate advice without a solid grasp of the hard data?
This may be common wisdom, but great advisers understand that this approach, while necessary, is not sufficient. It’s fundamentally incomplete. It’s like asking someone to solve a complex puzzle with only half the pieces; the final result will not match the picture on the box. Our review data highlights that deep discovery, skill and capability are the most salient indicators of quality advice.
To be clear, many advisers’ discovery processes are inadequate because traditional fact-finding too often ignores the ‘why’ behind the facts, overlooking the real reasons for the needs and objectives uncovered.
This crucial component is what we term ‘reason-finding’; in our view, understanding emotional drivers and implicit preferences is the key to elevating financial advice from a formulaic and pedestrian exercise to a truly transformative outcome.
Before you congratulate yourself on your process, I want to emphasise that “understanding” emotional drivers and implicit preferences requires more than the cursory consideration of the brief notes you wrote down in the margins of your data collection document.
The Limitations of Fact-Finding
“I know I have good judgement
I know I have good taste
It’s funny and it’s ironic.
That only I feel that way”Sabrina Carpenter, Please, Please, Please.
The problem with an exclusively fact-based approach is that it often leads to cookie-cutter solutions. After reviewing over 21,000 files, we know that when advisers principally focus on numerical data, they produce soulless, generic advice documents that usually fail to address their client’s unique needs, aspirations, and individual concerns. Good and Exceptional advice, on the other hand, is produced by financial advisers who utilise deep discovery processes to supplement, develop and contextualise the quantitative data.
Facts are essential, but too many advisers consider data alone the key to quality advice. This one-size-fits-all approach is not only ineffective but potentially harmful because it can lead to strategies that are misaligned with a client’s true objectives and risk appetite. You know that clients often struggle to understand and connect with advice that’s rational, factual and numerical but doesn’t speak to them or reflect their real needs. Advice encompassing their “why” results in more meaningful outcomes and better engagement.
We all know that the relationship between an advice professional and their client is an intimate and evolving one. Many advisers are highly skilled at establishing trust, showing empathy, and building rapport. However, too often, even these efforts are little more than brief stops on the path towards a product recommendation. Our data suggest that even where an adviser’s discovery process extends beyond the minimalistic data required by software providers, it’s too often limited to surface-level enquiries and superficial analysis. Appropriate, good and quality advice requires more.
Advisers can start by incorporating structured, open-ended questions into client meetings, allowing for deeper exploration of personal goals and fears. For instance, asking ‘What does financial freedom and security mean to you?’ can open avenues for understanding motivations that raw data alone cannot reveal.”
Consider two clients who both express a desire to retire at 60.
This fact might lead an adviser to develop similar financial plan strategies for both. However, the reasons behind this shared goal could be vastly different. One client might be eager to embark on a world tour, while the other may want to start a small business in their golden years. These divergent motivations would necessitate markedly different financial strategies despite the superficial similarity of the retirement age goal.
Similarly, an adviser may note a client’s preference for a conservative investment portfolio, but the adviser might miss crucial nuances without understanding the underlying reasons. Does this preference reflect the client’s risk-averse personality? Is it a result of previous negative experiences in the market? Or does it stem from a specific financial need or obligation, such as funding a child’s education or caring for elderly parents? These reasons would warrant a different approach to portfolio construction that an adviser with a “fact-focused” discovery process would overlook.
The Power of Reason-Finding
Reason-finding goes beyond the surface level of financial data. It delves into the motivations, fears, aspirations, and values that drive a client’s financial decisions. This deeper understanding is not just beneficial – it’s essential for crafting truly effective, appropriate and personalised advice.
By engaging in reason-finding, financial advisers can help clients:
- Create Tailored Solutions: A better understanding of the ‘why’ behind a client’s financial goals allows advisers to develop strategies that are genuinely aligned with the client’s needs and aspirations. This results in plans that are more effective and more likely to be adhered to by the client.
- Build Trust and Rapport: When clients feel genuinely understood, they’re more likely to open up about their deepest financial concerns and aspirations. This honesty and transparency lead to a stronger adviser-client relationship and more comprehensive financial planning.
- Anticipate Future Needs: By understanding the (often unarticulated) reasoning behind a client’s current financial situation and goals, advisers can better anticipate how these might evolve, allowing for more adaptable and forward-thinking strategies.
- Address Emotional Aspects of Finance: Money is inherently emotional. Reason-finding allows advisers to address financial decision-making’s psychological and emotional aspects, leading to more holistic and sustainable financial plans.
- Improve Client Education: When advisers understand the reasons behind a client’s financial beliefs and behaviours, they can provide more targeted and effective financial education, empowering clients to make better-informed decisions.
Implementing Reason-Finding in Financial Plan Practice
It may not require a quantum leap, but transitioning from a fact-centric to a reason-inclusive approach requires a shift in a team, mindset and methodology. Here are some strategies for incorporating reason-finding into financial planning practice::
- Ask Probing Questions: Instead of simply asking when a client wants to retire, inquire about their vision for retirement. Rather than just noting a savings goal, explore what the client hopes to achieve with those savings. When discussing risk tolerance, delve into past experiences that have shaped their attitude towards investing.
- Active Listening: Pay attention not just to the words clients use but also their tone, body language, and what they might be hesitant to express. Often, what’s left unsaid can be as revealing as what’s explicitly stated.
- Use Scenario-Based Discussions: Present hypothetical financial scenarios to clients and ask how they would feel and react in those situations. This can reveal underlying attitudes and priorities that might not surface in direct questioning.
- Employ Visualisation Techniques: Ask clients to describe their ideal financial future in detail. This can uncover aspirations and priorities that might need to be captured in traditional fact-finding questionnaires.
- Explore Family and Cultural Influences: Understand how a client’s upbringing, family dynamics, and cultural background have shaped their financial attitudes and behaviours.
- Revisit and Reassess Regularly: Reasons can change over time. Make reason-finding an ongoing process, not just a one-time exercise during the initial planning phase.
Challenges and Considerations in the Business Journey
While implementing a new approach may offer numerous benefits, it also presents challenges that financial advisers need to navigate carefully:
- Skill Development: Financial advisers may need to develop new skills such as emotional intelligence, active listening, and open-ended questioning. This might require training and practice to integrate reason-finding into their advice process effectively.
- Balancing Privacy: There is a fine line between understanding clients’ motivations and intruding into their personal lives. Advice professionals must be sensitive to clients’ comfort levels and respect their privacy, ensuring that questions and discussions remain within appropriate boundaries.
- Time Investment: Reason-finding can take time, which might seem counterproductive in an industry that values efficiency. However, the long-term benefits, such as improved client satisfaction and retention, can significantly outweigh the initial time investment.
Regulatory Implications
To be clear, the shift towards reason-finding presents opportunities and challenges for advisers and compliance.
On the one hand, a deeper understanding of client motivations can lead to more compelling and more appropriate advice, increasing engagement and reducing the risk of contravening best interest duties. On the other hand, it requires a more nuanced approach to documenting the advice process and justifying recommendations.
The reason for the shift is obvious. In a post-disclosure regulatory regime, ASIC’s focus on outcomes rather than just processes signals the need to reorient towards engagement, consent, and understanding. This aligns well with the reason-finding approach, which aims to achieve better outcomes by understanding clients’ underlying motivations and providing more tailored and appropriate advice.
In an environment where almost every aspect of the financial planning process can be outsourced or disrupted by technology, an adviser’s capacity to understand and connect with a client is the bedrock of an ongoing advice relationship. For purely pragmatic reasons, advisers must recognise the increasing importance of soft skills in financial planning.
“Reason-finding” aligns with this trend, emphasising the need for business advisers to develop stronger interpersonal skills to supplement and support their technical expertise.
Conclusion
The shift from fact-finding to reason-finding represents a significant evolution in financial planning. While gathering factual data remains essential, understanding the reasons behind these facts truly empowers financial advisers to create meaningful, personalised, and practical strategies for their clients.
By embracing reason-finding, financial advisers can elevate their practice, deepen client relationships, and ultimately deliver more value. This approach recognises the complexity of financial decision-making and acknowledges that there’s a whole life and human story behind every number.
As the financial advice profession struggles to emerge from distribution, those who master the art of “reason-finding” and move beyond superficial compliance processes will be better positioned to meet stakeholders’ changing needs and expectations and satisfy their professional and legal obligations. They’ll be able to recommend strategies and services that don’t just look good on paper but genuinely resonate with clients’ deepest motivations and aspirations.
In the end, effective financial planning isn’t just about accounting and managing money—it’s about understanding people and why they want what they want. That understanding will not be achieved by asking what, when, or how much but by exploring why.
Contact us today to explore how Assured Support can assist you in transitioning businesses to a reason-finding approach, enhancing your client relationships, and ensuring compliance with the latest regulatory standards.
If you liked this, we recommend that you read:
Reviewers’ Hot Takes: Four paths to better advice
