FAQ

What distinguishes a “complete file” from a “defensible file” from a “good file”?

ASIC expects AFS licensees and advisers to maintain records that demonstrate appropriate advice, where a complete file contains all required documents, a defensible file evidences the reasoning linking client circumstances to recommendations, and a good file clearly articulates client-centric advice with transparent, logical, and well-structured justification.

Expanded Answer
ASIC’s focus is not on document presence alone but on whether advice can be understood and justified. A “complete file” is administrative—it includes all required documents such as fact finds, SOAs, file notes, and disclosures. However, completeness does not demonstrate that the advice is appropriate or compliant.

A “defensible file” goes further by evidencing the advice process. It shows a clear line of sight from client objectives and circumstances through to strategy and product recommendations. The file contains contemporaneous notes, documented assumptions, consideration of alternatives, and clear reasoning that supports the advice. This is the standard ASIC and AFCA rely on when assessing appropriateness.

A “good file” builds on defensibility by being clear, concise, and client-centric. It explains the advice in a logically structured, easy-to-follow way, clearly articulating risks, trade-offs, and decisions. It reflects professional judgement, not just compliance. For practical benchmarks, see A practical guide to high-level file reviews for licensees and advisers and Info 292: clear, captured and client-centric.

Why it matters
Files that are complete, but not defensible, are a primary cause of adverse ASIC findings and AFCA determinations. Regulators assess reasoning and appropriateness, not document volume, making defensibility critical to reducing enforcement and remediation risk.

Unsure how this applies to you?
Get a clear answer in a 15-minute call with a compliance specialist. Book your call.

Practical guidance

  • Ensure all required documents are present, but focus on capturing the reasoning behind each advice step.
  • Document a clear linkage between client objectives, strategy, and product selection with contemporaneous evidence.
  • Structure advice records so they are easy to follow, with clear explanations of decisions, risks, and trade-offs.

Further reading
Documenting the strategy and selection process
Understanding client suitability: beyond Standard 5

Subscribe

Every fortnight “Three Hit Tuesday” delivers thought leadership, considered analysis and insights that will help you improve your advice, more effectively manage your regulatory risks and make you better informed than your peers.

AS-Subscribe Form

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We respect your privacy. We know everyone says that, but we promise that we won’t sell your contact details to dodgy telemarketers, spam your email or otherwise exploit your trust.

Step 1 of 8 - Your Role

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Assess your ASIC exposure

Answer a few targeted questions to identify where your compliance may not stand up under ASIC review.

Takes less than 2 minutes. No preparation required.

What best describes your role?