ASIC expects Statements of Advice to clearly demonstrate how advice is appropriate and in the client’s best interests, where strong SOAs show a clear, client-specific link between objectives, strategy and recommendations, and weak SOAs rely on generic content, unclear reasoning, and poor alignment with the client’s circumstances.
Expanded Answer
ASIC’s guidance emphasises that an SOA must communicate the basis of advice and demonstrate appropriateness. Strong SOAs are built on a clear line of sight from client objectives and circumstances through to strategy and product recommendations. They explain why the advice is suitable, outline risks and trade-offs, and reflect the client’s specific situation rather than generic scenarios.
In practice, strong SOAs are concise, structured, and client-centric. They clearly articulate the problem being solved, the strategy adopted, alternatives considered, and why the recommended products meet the client’s needs. Assumptions are transparent, fees are clearly explained, and the reasoning is easy to follow. Weak SOAs, by contrast, are often templated, overly long, or filled with irrelevant disclosures. They may state conclusions without explanation, fail to address client priorities, or lack evidence of strategy selection and product comparison.
Regulatory scrutiny increases where SOAs are complex but unclear, or where disclosure substitutes for reasoning. ASIC has consistently signalled that length and technical detail do not equate to quality. For practical insights, see Documenting the strategy and selection process and TL;DR: why the SOA wastes everybody’s time.
Why it matters
Weak SOAs are a common driver of ASIC findings and client complaints because they fail to demonstrate appropriateness. Strong SOAs reduce regulatory risk by making the advice process transparent, logical, and defensible.
Unsure how this applies to you?
Get a clear answer in a 15-minute call with a compliance specialist. Book your call.
Practical guidance
- Focus the SOA on client-specific objectives, clearly linking them to strategy and recommendations.
- Explain the reasoning behind the advice, including alternatives, risks, and trade-offs, not just the outcome.
- Remove generic or irrelevant content and ensure disclosures support, rather than obscure, the advice rationale.
Further reading
Info 292: clear, captured and client-centric
Understanding client suitability: beyond Standard 5