ASIC does not prescribe a fixed list of indicators that require closer supervision of an adviser. However, AFS licensees should increase supervision when evidence suggests an adviser presents a higher compliance, conduct or consumer risk. Supervision should be proportionate to the identified risks and adjusted as those risks change over time.
Expanded Answer
AFS licensees are responsible for supervising their representatives and maintaining adequate arrangements to ensure financial services are provided in accordance with their licence obligations. Closer supervision is appropriate where objective evidence indicates an increased likelihood of compliance failures, poor advice quality or client harm. The focus should be on identifying emerging risks early rather than responding only after significant breaches occur.
Common warning signs include recurring file review findings, poor-quality file notes, repeated documentation deficiencies, client complaints, breaches of internal policies, inconsistent application of advice processes, delayed remediation, unusual product concentration, high volumes of advice requiring correction and resistance to compliance feedback. Other indicators include declining training outcomes, repeated failures in compliance attestation, significant changes in business volume or advice scope, and prior disciplinary or regulatory action.
Closer supervision may include more frequent file reviews, pre-vet approval of advice, targeted coaching, additional compliance monitoring, restrictions on authorised activities or more frequent management reporting.
Key indicators:
- Recurring compliance deficiencies across multiple files.
- Evidence that advice processes are not being followed consistently.
- Increasing complaints, breaches or remediation activity.
- Failure to address previously identified compliance issues.
Risk indicators should be assessed collectively rather than in isolation. A structured, risk-based supervision framework enables licensees to allocate oversight where it is most needed and demonstrate that supervisory decisions are evidence-based. For further guidance, see Hiring right: how to spot a high-risk adviser before ASIC does.
Why it matters
Failing to increase supervision when warning signs emerge can allow isolated issues to develop into systemic compliance failures. Risk-based supervision helps protect clients, supports advice quality and demonstrates that the licensee is actively managing conduct risk.
Unsure how this applies to you?
Get a clear answer in a 15-minute call with a compliance specialist. Book your call
Practical guidance
- Define objective risk indicators that trigger enhanced supervision of advisers.
- Review supervision levels whenever file reviews, complaints or breaches identify recurring issues.
- Document the reasons for increased supervision and monitor whether risk levels improve.
Further reading
Hiring right: how to spot a high-risk adviser before ASIC does
Financial adviser red flags: key signs of potential misconduct
From samples to signals: a smarter approach to AFSL surveillance